Clinical Description
In contrast to prior classification schemes, the most recent 2020 reclassification system distinguishes between EBS, defined by blistering within the basal keratinocytes, and other disorders with skin fragility that lack significant blistering as a result of superficial skin cleavage above the basal keratinocytes [Has et al 2020a].
The most common forms of EBS – localized EBS, intermediate EBS, severe EBS, and EBS with mottled pigmentation – are distinguished primarily on dermatologic, genetic, and histopathologic findings. The clinical features of these disorders are summarized in Table 2. Rare subtypes including several distinct syndromes have also been identified.
Table 2.
Select Features of the Four Most Common EBS Subtypes
View in own window
Clinical Features | EBS Subtype |
---|
Localized | Intermediate | Severe | W/mottled pigmentation |
---|
Age of onset
| Infancy, usually by 12-18 mos | Birth/infancy | Birth | Birth/infancy |
Blisters
|
|
|
|
|
Hyperkeratosis
of palms & soles
(keratoderma)
| Occasionally | Occasionally | Common, progressive, & diffuse | Common, focal |
Nail involvement
| Occasionally | Occasionally | Common | Occasionally |
Milia
| Rare | Occasionally | Common | Unknown |
Hyper-/
hypopigmentation
| No | Can occur | Common | Always |
Localized EBS
Localized EBS, the most common EBS subtype, occurs in approximately 60% of individuals with EBS. Blisters begin in infancy and can present at birth; severity is usually mild. The first episodes may occur on the knees and shins with crawling or on the feet at approximately age 12-18 months, after walking is firmly established. Some affected individuals do not manifest the disease until adolescence or early adult life. Although blisters are usually confined to the hands and feet, they can occur anywhere given adequate trauma; for example, blisters can develop on the buttocks after horseback riding or around the waist after wearing a tight belt.
Symptoms can be seasonal, worsening with warm weather and sweating. The palms and soles are usually more involved than the backs of the hands and the tops of the feet, and lesions may be associated with pain and pruritus resulting in reduced mobility during active disease flares. Affected individuals may additionally develop hyperhidrosis of the palms and soles, which in turn can further worsen blistering. Mucosal involvement is rare. Focal hyperkeratosis of the palms and soles at sites of repeated mechanical friction and trauma can develop beginning in late childhood and early adulthood and can cause significant pain and reduced mobility. Occasionally, a large blister in a nail bed may result in shedding of the nail.
Severe EBS
Severe EBS occurs in approximately 25% of individuals with EBS. Onset is usually at birth and severity varies greatly both between and within families. Blisters may be large, hemorrhagic, and severe, particularly within the neonatal period. In newborns, there may be significant overlap in clinical presentation with other forms of inherited EB, including dystrophic EB and junctional EB. Widespread and severe blistering and/or multiple grouped clumps of small blisters are typical. Hemorrhagic blisters are common. Mucosal involvement such as oral and esophageal blisters and erosions can occur and may interfere with feeding, particularly during infancy and early childhood; this usually improves with age. Laryngeal involvement including laryngeal stenoses or strictures may manifest as hoarseness but is not life threatening. Decreased frequency of blistering occurs during mid- to late childhood and blistering may be a minimal component of the disorder in adult life. Dysphagia and constipation are uncommon but can develop in a subset of individuals; other gastrointestinal involvement more frequently identified in other forms of inherited EB (e.g., esophageal strictures) are not observed in EBS. Progressive hyperkeratosis (focal or diffuse) of the palms and soles begins in childhood and may be the major feature in affected adults. Nail dystrophy (thickened, deformed nails) is common. Both hyper- and hypopigmentation can occur, typically in areas of blistering. Increased cumulative risk of basal cell carcinomas have been identified in individuals with severe EBS; however, increased development of basal cell carcinomas has not been observed in localized EBS or intermediate EBS [Fine et al 2009].
EBS with Mottled Pigmentation
EBS with mottled pigmentation is rare and occurs in fewer than 1% of individuals with EBS. Skin fragility is evident at birth and is clinically indistinguishable from that seen in generalized forms of EBS, including severe EBS. The defining characteristic is the development of small hyperpigmented macules that begin to appear in early childhood, progress over time, and coalesce to a reticulate pattern. Hypopigmented macules may be interspersed. These changes tend to develop on the trunk (particularly in flexural areas; e.g., the neck, groin, and axillae) and then on the extremities (particularly the arms). This pigmentation is not preceded by blistering, which distinguishes it from post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation and hypopigmentation, and often disappears during adulthood. Focal palmar and plantar hyperkeratoses may occur.
Additional Rare Forms of EBS
Recessive EBS, intermediate or severe with KRT14 or KRT5 pathogenic variants. Individuals with biallelic loss-of-function variants in KRT14 or KRT5 generally present with severe, generalized blistering at birth (which may not improve with age, in contrast to EBS caused by heterozygous dominant-negative variants in KRT14 or KRT5) and may develop keratoderma, nail dystrophy, oral and genital erosions, anemia, and post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation at the site of prior lesions [Yiasemides et al 2008, García et al 2011, Diociaiuti et al 2018, Tryon et al 2019, Vahidnezhad et al 2019a].
EBS associated with PLEC pathogenic variants ranges widely in presentation, from limited cutaneous blistering and scarring without systemic involvement (e.g., EBS, intermediate with PLEC pathogenic variants), to generalized blistering with muscular dystrophy and cardiomyopathy (e.g., EBS, intermediate with muscular dystrophy), to life-threatening generalized blistering with pyloric atresia and early death (e.g., EBS, severe with pyloric atresia). Phenotypes vary based on the type of PLEC variant and the presence of a heterozygous or biallelic variant(s) [Kiritsi et al 2021].
EBS, intermediate with PLEC pathogenic variants are most often associated with heterozygous
PLEC pathogenic variants; however, biallelic
PLEC pathogenic variants have been reported in rare cases [
Gostyńska et al 2015,
Khan et al 2021]. The heterozygous pathogenic missense variant (
c.5998C>T; p.Arg2000Trp) within the rod domain of
PLEC [
Koss-Harnes et al 2002,
Kiritsi et al 2013] causes the subtype formerly known as EBS-Ogna. Clinical features include limited, relatively mild blistering following trauma with bruising, hypopigmentation following blister formation, nail dystrophy, and no internal involvement. Transmission electron microscopy (TEM) of a skin biopsy identified the cleavage plane to be just above the inner plates of the hemidesmosomes in the deep basal cell cytoplasm; immunofluorescent mapping showed reduced and/or patchy plectin staining.
EBS, intermediate with muscular dystrophy is associated with biallelic pathogenic variants in
PLEC. Cutaneous findings include intermediate, generalized blistering and nail dystrophy or loss; severe-to-life-threatening involvement of the oral, laryngeal, and urethral mucosa can also occur [
Schara et al 2004,
Prodinger et al 2017,
Bourhis et al 2019]. Onset of muscular dystrophy ranges from infancy to adulthood [
Kyrova et al 2016,
Winter et al 2016], and progressive muscle weakness can result in death for affected individuals by the third or fourth decade of life. Other clinical manifestations include myasthenic symptoms [
Forrest et al 2010] and cardiomyopathy, which may be life threatening [
Bolling et al 2010,
Villa et al 2015]. Pyloric atresia is rare [
Natsuga et al 2010]. TEM reveals a plane of cleavage (level of separation) within the bottom layer of the basal keratinocytes, just above the hemidesmosomes.
EBS, severe with pyloric atresia is associated with biallelic premature termination variants in
PLEC. Disease course is severe and usually lethal in neonates, although rare survival past the neonatal period has been reported [
Charlesworth et al 2013,
Walker et al 2017]. Clinical features include pyloric atresia, anemia, ear anomalies, growth deficiency, and joint contractures. Extensive, generalized congenital absence of the skin (congenital aplasia cutis) may also be present [
Mariath et al 2021] and is also a significant cause of early mortality.
EBS with migratory circinate erythema is caused by heterozygous pathogenic variants in KRT5 and is associated with the development of small, often intensely pruritic blisters, frequently on the extremities or following trauma, against a background of migratory and circinate erythema and brown post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation from healing lesions [Castiglia et al 2014, Yalici-Armagan et al 2020]. Blistering may improve with age, and nail dystrophy may be present.
EBS, intermediate with cardiomyopathy is associated with heterozygous pathogenic variants within the initiation codon of KLHL24. Blistering can be severe and generalized at birth but improve with age. Cutaneous manifestations also include whorled hyper- or hypopigmentation, palmoplantar keratoderma, nail dystrophy and thickening, and hair loss. Congenital aplasia cutis may be present [Mariath et al 2021]. Importantly, individuals may develop early-onset progressive dilated cardiomyopathy that can lead to premature death [He et al 2016, Lee et al 2017, Alkhalifah et al 2018, Yenamandra et al 2018, Grilletta 2019, Schwieger-Briel et al 2019].
EBS, localized or intermediate with BP230 deficiency is caused by reduced or absent expression of BP230 (i.e., epithelial BPAG1, BPAG1-e) due to biallelic loss-of-function variants in DST. Clinical manifestations include relatively mild blistering (primarily localized to acral surfaces) and keratoderma [Groves et al 2010, Liu et al 2012, Takeichi et al 2015, Ganani et al 2021].
EBS, localized or intermediate with exophilin 5 deficiency is associated with biallelic EXPH5 pathogenic variants resulting in absent exophilin 5. This subtype is characterized by generally mild blistering (particularly in an acral distribution) that improves with age, easy bleeding, and mild, generalized mottled reticulated hyperpigmentation [Liu et al 2014, Turcan et al 2016, Diociaiuti et al 2020].
EBS, localized with nephropathy with CD151 deficiency. Affected individuals have biallelic loss-of-function variants in CD151. Mucocutaneous symptoms include blistering that may be widespread or primarily on the shins, poikiloderma, nail dystrophy, acrogeria, alopecia, mucosal erosions, and esophageal strictures; systemic manifestations are notable for nephropathy resulting in proteinuria [Vahidnezhad et al 2018]. Epilepsy has also been reported in association with this rare EBS subtype [Dunn et al 2022].
Secondary Complications
Infection is a common secondary complication in EBS, particularly among individuals with extensive body surface area involvement or chronic wounds, and may range from wound colonization (bacteria are present that can impede wound healing) to overt infection with clinical signs of infection such as purulence, drainage, erythema, and pain. Complications of infections include deep tissue involvement (cellulitis), bone involvement (osteomyelitis), or systemic disease (sepsis) if not treated.
Infections may be associated with significant morbidity and mortality, particularly among neonates and infants with severe EBS who are at increased risk of death due to sepsis [Fine et al 2008b]. Infected or colonized wounds may also be painful or pruritic, and resultant chronic inflammation from longstanding non-healing wounds may contribute to anemia or nutritional deficiencies. Bacterial species commonly identified within wounds include Staphylococcus aureus, Streptococci, and Pseudomonas aeruginosa [Brandling-Bennett & Morel 2010, Levin et al 2021]. Antibiotic resistance resulting from repeated infections is common.
Pain and itch are extremely common and can be severe and debilitating, even in individuals with localized EBS [Brun et al 2017, Bruckner et al 2020, So et al 2022]. Pain and itch are associated with repeated cycles of wounding and healing and are often worsened during active disease flares. These symptoms may significantly impact quality of life, psychosocial well-being, and ability to participate in school and work.
Fluid and electrolyte disturbances range widely in neonates with EBS, and causes are multifactorial. Rapid demise in neonates and infants can occur with extensive skin involvement and severe skin fragility (e.g., as in newborns presenting with congenital aplasia cutis) as a result of significant transepidermal water loss, electrolyte abnormalities, systemic inflammation, and hypermetabolic state. Nutritional support and close monitoring may be crucial for infants and children with severe EBS or intermediate EBS who have more generalized involvement. Infants with significant oral disease may develop an aversion to feeding that persists even after oral disease improves. Dehydration and electrolyte imbalances may exacerbate the disease secondary to impeded wound healing, growth, and development. Chronic anemia may develop during both childhood and adulthood as a result of chronic inflammation from ongoing blistering and wounding.
Keratoderma (thickened skin on the hands and feet) is common in all EBS subtypes, with approximately 76% of individuals developing plantar keratoderma over their lifetime in one recent study [Reimer-Taschenbrecker et al 2021]. Plantar keratoderma is a painful and often debilitating secondary complication of EBS, and can contribute to disease-related obesity, impaired mobility, and loss of bone density due insufficient weight bearing. Focal plantar keratoderma at sites of mechanical trauma and pressure on the feet may be present in all EBS subtypes, including localized EBS; however, diffuse plantar keratoderma is observed primarily among individuals with intermediate EBS and severe EBS.
Impaired mobility, obesity, and metabolic disease. Children with EBS may have delay in walking. Individuals with all EBS subtypes may experience difficulties walking because of painful blisters, erosions, and keratoses on the feet. Adolescents and adults with both mild and severe forms EBS are at increased risk of becoming overweight or obese [So et al 2022], a clinical feature distinct from other forms of inherited EB. Causes for excess weight gain include a sedentary lifestyle due to reduced mobility and ability to participate in physical activities as a result of painful blisters and keratoderma on the feet, and decreased oral involvement with age [Haynes 2010, Yerlett 2020, Reimer-Taschenbrecker et al 2021]. However, medical complications associated with obesity such as type 2 diabetes, cardiovascular disease, and/or stroke have not yet been characterized specifically among individuals with EBS.
Quality of life and psychosocial considerations. Individuals may experience reduced quality of life and significant psychosocial and economic challenges as a result of EBS, including feelings of anxiety, frustration, and depression, strained interpersonal relationships with family, financial burden due to the cost of wound dressing supplies and medications, and reduced employment opportunities [Tabolli et al 2009, Williams et al 2011, Brun et al 2017, Bruckner et al 2020, So et al 2022]. Individuals may also miss school or work, particularly during active disease flares.
Cancer risk. Squamous cell carcinoma is not usually associated with EBS. Individuals with severe EBS are at increased risk for basal cell carcinoma; however, this heightened risk has not been observed in other EBS subtypes [Fine et al 2009].
Nomenclature
In 1886, Koebner coined the term epidermolysis bullosa hereditaria. In the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, Brocq and Hallopeau coined the terms traumatic pemphigus, congenital traumatic blistering, and acantholysis bullosa; these terms are no longer in use [Fine et al 1999].
The nomenclature for EBS has changed five times in the last 20 years. The eponyms EBS-Weber-Cockayne and EBS-Koebner were changed to EBS, localized and EBS, other generalized in the 2008 classification system [Fine et al 2008a]. A new classification system was developed in 2014, referred to as the "onion skin" terminology, which considers the level of blistering, phenotypic characteristics including distribution and severity of cutaneous blisters and wounding, and associated gene [Fine et al 2014].
In February 2020, the most recent reclassification system for EB and other skin fragility disorders was published following the 2019 international consensus meeting [Has et al 2020a]. This 2020 consensus reclassification system incorporates genotype-phenotype associations and novel pathogenic variants identified in affected individuals (see Table 4).
Table 4.
Comparison of 2008 Epidermolysis Bullosa Simplex Nomenclature with 2020 Nomenclature
View in own window
2008 Nomenclature 1 | 2020 Nomenclature 2 |
---|
EBS, localized | Localized EBS, normal keratin 5 & 14 staining, KRT5 or KRT14 pathogenic variant (specify type) |
EBS, generalized other | Intermediate EBS, normal keratin 5 & 14 staining, KRT5 or KRT14 pathogenic variant (specify type) |
EBS-MP | EBS w/mottled pigmentation, normal keratin 5 staining, KRT5 pathogenic variant (specify type) |
EBS, Dowling-Meara | Severe EBS, normal keratin 5 & 14 staining, KRT5 or KRT14 pathogenic variant (specify type) |
EBS = epidermolysis bullosa simplex; MP = mottled pigmentation
- 1.
- 2.