Clinical Description
Canavan disease is a leukodystrophy characterized by neurodevelopmental delays, macrocephaly, and tone abnormalities. The phenotypic spectrum ranges from the more severe typical Canavan disease (~85%-90% of individuals) to the less severe atypical Canavan disease (10%-15%) [Bley et al 2021].
In typical Canavan disease, neurodevelopmental impairment becomes evident by ages three to five months and is followed by neurodegeneration and developmental regression.
In atypical Canavan disease, neurodevelopmental delay usually becomes evident in the first years of life, frequently followed by developmental regression later in childhood or adolescence; however, the clinical course is more variable than in typical Canavan disease.
Individuals with Canavan disease have a reduced life expectancy, with 73% surviving to age ten years and a minority of individuals living to adulthood, as reported in a cohort comprising individuals with typical and atypical Canavan disease [Bley et al 2021].
Typical Canavan Disease
Presentation. Infants appear normal early in life, but by age three to five months, hypotonia, head lag, accelerated head growth leading to macrocephaly, and developmental delays become apparent.
Hypotonia is an early finding associated with poor head control. Inability to support the head is a constant feature of this disorder. With age, hypotonia evolves to spasticity.
Macrocephaly. Head circumference is typically normal at birth. However, in the course of typical Canavan disease, the majority of infants develop progressive macrocephaly between ages four and 18 months.
Developmental delay is an early finding but becomes more obvious with age. Children are delayed in their motor and language skills and are not able to sit, stand, walk, or talk.
More than half of affected children develop a social smile and laugh. The minority are able to reach for objects and use their hands purposefully.
Seizures are common and can include a variety of seizure types, including tonic spasms, generalized tonic-clonic, and infantile epileptic spasms syndrome [Karimzadeh et al 2014; Masri & Wahsh 2014; A Nagy, personal observation]. Seizures occur in the first year of life in one third of children with Canavan disease and become more prevalent over time, occurring in the vast majority by the end of the first decade and often persisting despite treatment with anti-seizure medications [Bley et al 2021].
Vision. Early in life there is a decreased ability to fix and follow, most commonly due to cerebral visual impairment [Bley et al 2021], broadly defined here as bilateral visual impairment due to a non-ocular cause (i.e., based in the brain) in the presence of normal ocular function. It may be due to involvement of the cortex (i.e., cortical visual impairment) or other parts of the brain as well. Optic atrophy has also been reported as a cause of visual impairment in Canavan disease. Nystagmus frequently develops early in infancy.
Hearing is usually not impaired.
Progression. With age, children with typical Canavan disease often become irritable and experience sleep disturbance, seizures, and feeding difficulties. Swallowing deteriorates, and some children require gastrostomy tube placement. Hypertonia increases over time, and previously acquired developmental skills are lost.
Prognosis. Most children with typical Canavan disease die in the first two decades of life [Bley et al 2021]. This survival is longer than previously reported and likely due to improved medical and nursing care.
Atypical Canavan Disease
Presentation. The spectrum of clinical presentations associated with atypical Canavan disease is wider than that of typical Canavan disease. Children with atypical Canavan disease may have normal or mildly delayed speech and/or motor development early in life.
Many children with atypical Canavan disease have normal head size, although macrocephaly is also seen.
In spite of developmental delay, most of these children participate in classroom settings and may benefit from an individualized education plan or other educational intervention [Matalon & Michals Matalon 2015].
Other findings in some individuals can include retinitis pigmentosa and seizures [Tacke et al 2005, Delaney et al 2015, Benson et al 2021].
Ataxia, coordination difficulties, and gait disturbances are frequently reported in atypical Canavan disease [Yalcinkaya et al 2005, Janson et al 2006, Nguyen & Ishak 2015, Sarret et al 2016, Kotambail et al 2023].
Progression. Children with atypical Canavan disease frequently continue to make slow developmental progress without regression until later in the disease course. Although these individuals often gain the ability to walk, some have significant language impairment and are diagnosed with intellectual disability [Sarret et al 2016, Kimiskidis et al 2017, Kotambail et al 2023].
Prognosis. The life span is not well-described; however, individuals with atypical Canavan disease may survive to adulthood.
Genotype-Phenotype Correlations
Genotype-phenotype correlations have been proposed with the following classes of variants depending on the effect of these variants on residual aspartoacylase enzyme activity (see Table 6).
The two common ASPA pathogenic variants in the Ashkenazi Jewish population, p.Tyr231Ter and p.Glu285Ala, cause complete loss of aspartoacylase activity and are associated with typical Canavan disease either in the homozygous or compound heterozygous state [Matalon & Michals-Matalon 1998].
The p.Ala305Glu pathogenic variant is a common variant in European individuals without Ashkenazi Jewish ancestry. This pathogenic variant is associated with very low aspartoacylase activity and has been identified in individuals with typical and atypical Canavan disease (both in the homozygous and compound heterozygous state with another mild variant) [Shaag et al 1995, Janson et al 2006, Mendes et al 2017].
ASPA pathogenic variants with higher residual aspartoacylase activity (e.g., p.Arg71His, p.Asp204His, p.Pro257Arg, p.Tyr288Cys) are associated with atypical Canavan disease [Mendes et al 2017]. Of note, these pathogenic variants can be associated with atypical Canavan disease whether in the homozygous or compound heterozygous state, including with pathogenic variants associated with complete loss of aspartoacylase activity [Surendran et al 2003, Yalcinkaya et al 2005, Kurczynski & Victorio 2011, Michals & Matalon 2011].