Cochrane systematic reviews |
---|
Chinuck 2014 Cochrane SR | Appetite stimulants versus placebo (Eubanks 2002, Homnick 2004, Marchand 2000) | Adults and children with CF |
Change in weight (kg) Change in weight z score Change in FEV1 (% predicted) Number of pulmonary exacerbations Number of adverse effects
| |
Goldbeck 2014 Cochrane SR | Comparison 1. Behavioural intervention versus usual care (Stark 1996) Comparison 2. Behavioural management training plus educational intervention versus educational intervention alone (Powers 2003, Stark 2009) | Children or adults with CF |
Change in weight (kg) Change in weight z score Change in BMI z score Change in % ideal body weight Change in weight % for age Change in height (cm) Change in height z score Change in FEV1 % predicted
| |
Morton 2015 Cochrane SR | Supplemental enteral tube feeding for 1 month or longer versus no specific intervention (No studies were included) | People with CF of any age | No studies were identified for inclusion in this review | |
Savage 2014 Cochrane SR | Nutrition education versus usual care (Watson 2008) | Individuals of all ages with CF or family members or both |
| |
Smyth 2014 Cochrane SR | Comparison 1. Oral calorie supplementation versus usual care (Hanning 1993, Poustie 2006) Comparison 2. Oral calorie supplementation versus additional nutritional advice (Kalnins 2005) | People with CF |
Change in weight (kg) Change in weight centile (percentile points) Change in weight z score Change in BMI (kg/m2) Change in BMI centile (percentile points) Change in weight for height (percentage) Change in height (cm) Change in height centile (percentile points) Change in height z score Change in FEV1 (% predicted)
| |
Primary studies included in SRs |
---|
Eubanks 2002 USA RCT | Intervention: Appetite stimulant
Control: Placebo | N=17 participants (intervention: n=10; placebo: n=7)
|
| Included in Chinuck 2014 SR Duration: 6 months. After completion of the 6-month trial, the placebo group was offered MA for a further 6 months. Population was considered as direct. |
Hanning 1993 Canada RCT | Intervention: oral calorie supplements Dietary supplements, drink powders, milk shakes, tinned puddings to achieve 25% of normal energy recommendations in addition to normal diet for 6 months Control: usual care | N=20 children and young people with CF (20 randomised, 16 studied)
|
Change in weight (kg) Change in weight a s% expected for age and height Change in height as % of expected for age Change in FEV1 % predicted
| Included in Smyth 2014 SR Follow-up: 6 months Population was considered as indirect. |
Homnick 2004 USA RCT | Intervention: Appetite stimulant Cyproheptadine hydrochloride 4mg 4 × daily Control: Placebo | N=18 people with CF enrolled, 16 completed study (intervention: n=8; placebo: n=8)
|
| Included in Chinuck 2014 SR Follow-up: 3 months Population was considered as indirect. |
Kalnins 2005 Canada Quasi-randomised controlled trial | Intervention: Oral calorie supplementation
Control: Nutritional counselling
|
N=15 participants with CF were enrolled but 2 dropped out Participants were aged >10 years. Mean (SD) age on entry to trial: advice group: 16.4 years (6.7); supplement group: 19.5 years (11.3). < 90% ideal WFH or 5% reduction in ideal WFH over 3 months
|
Change in weight (kg) Change in weight z score Change in weight for height (%) Change in % ideal body weight Change in height (cm) Change in height z score Change in FEV1 (% predicted)
| Included in Smyth 2014 SR Interventions implemented for 3 months, follow-up: 3 and 6 months Population was considered as direct. |
Marchand 2000 USA RCT | Intervention: Appetite stimulant
Control: Placebo | N=12 children with CF
Age: mean age 7.4 years. Range: 21 months to 10.4 years Inclusion criteria were loss of weight or plateau in weight gain for more than 3 months, weight-for-height less than 85%, and a negative change in weight z score
|
Change in weight z score Number of pulmonary exacerbations Fasting blood glucose levels Decreased morning cortisol levels
| Included in Chinuck 2014 SR Clinical assessment at week 0, 6, 12, 24 and 36 Population was considered as direct. |
Poustie 2006 UK RCT | Intervention 1: Oral calorie supplements Intervention 2: Routine dietary advice (usual care) | N=102 children and young people aged 2 - 15 years with CF
|
Change in weight (kg) Change in weight centile (percentile points) Change in BMI (kg/m2) Change in BMI centile (percentile points) Change in height (cm) Change in height centile (percentile points) Change in FEV1 % predicted
| Included in Smyth 2014 SR Interventions implemented for 12 months. Outcomes at 3, 6 and 12 months Population was considered as direct. |
Powers 2003 USA RCT | Intervention 1: Behavioural management training plus educational intervention
Intervention 2: Educational intervention only | N=12 infants and children with CF
(intervention 1: n=7, intervention 2: n=5). Age: Less than 3 years old. Pancreatic insufficiency.
|
| Included in Goldbeck 2014 SR Both groups received 8 sessions (45 to 60 minutes) over 1 year: Sessions 1 to 4 (3 months) intensive education Follow-up: 1 years Population was considered as direct. |
Stark 1996 USA RCT | Intervention: Group behavioural intervention.
7 weekly sessions - baseline assessment plus snack, breakfast, relaxation skills training, lunch, dinner and maintenance strategies targeted over following 7 sessions.
Control: Usual care (Wait list control)
| N=10 children with CF.
1 withdrew from control group after randomisation. Total sample n = 9 (intervention group: n=5, control group: n=4). Age range: 5.3 years to 10.1 years; mean (SD) age: 7.3 years (1.7).
|
| Included in Goldbeck 2014 SR Duration of interventions: 6 weeks Population was considered as indirect. |
Stark 2009 USA RCT | Intervention 1: Behavioural intervention
Behavioural intervention in group setting for change around nutrition an energy (Be-In-CHARGE!; n = 33) (available online at www.oup.com/us/pediatricpsych).
Intervention 2: Nutrition education
| N=79 children and young people with CF
Number randomised, n = 79 Received the intervention, n=67 (behavioural intervention plus nutrition education: n = 33, nutrition education: n = 34) Age: 4 to 12 years With pancreatic insufficiency; and weight for age and height ≤ 40th percentile.
|
| Included in Goldbeck 2014 SR Duration of interventions: 9 weeks. Timing of sessions: 7 sessions (each 90 minutes): pretreatment (session 1), 2 weeks later 5 weekly groups sessions (sessions 2 to 6), 2 weeks later post-treatment (session 7; follow up) Follow-up: up to 2 years Population was considered as direct. |
Watson 2008 UK RCT | Intervention: Nutrition education
General and disease-specific nutrition education (’Eat Well with CF’) Content: knowledge on general and disease-specific nutrition topics; self-management skills on goal setting in small incremental steps to establish new behaviours Mode of delivery: written material; supplementary workshops (introductory, weeks 5 and 10) and weekly telephone calls delivered by a dietitian
Control: Usual care | N=74 people with CF older than 16 years of age
participants were enrolled and stratified by disease severity into low or high risk disease. Participants were randomly allocated into intervention (n = 37) and control (n = 37) group 48 participants completed the study through to 12-month follow-up assessment (23 in intervention group, 25 in control group) Age: intervention group 26.4 (17.2–43.2) years; control group 24.2 (16.9–38.1) years
|
| Included in Savage 2014 SR Duration of the intervention: 10 weeks. Outcomes measured at 6 and 12 months Population was considered as indirect. |
Additional primary studies |
---|
Bradley 2012 United States Cohort study | Intervention: Gastrostomy Control: No gastrostomy (usual care) | N=40 people with CF (20 in the intervention group, 20 in the control group)
Age range: 2 to 20 years Each child in the intervention group was pair-matched on age, sex, pancreatic status, BMI and lung function with a children from the control group Children who had a gastrostomy for reasons other than nutritional supplementation were excluded
|
| Outcomes measured at 6 and 12 months Population was considered as direct. |
Powers 2015 USA RCT | Behavioural intervention
Control: education and attention control treatment
| N=78 children with CF and pancreatic insufficiency (intervention: n=36, control: n=42)
|
| Both treatments were delivered in person or telehealth (via telephone) Sessions occurred weekly for 8 weeks then monthly for 4 months (6 months). The control arm served as a behavioural placebo controlling for attention and contact frequency. Participants then returned to standard care for 1 year. Follow-up: 18 months Population was considered as direct. |
White 2013 UK Cohort study | Intervention: Enteral tube feeding
Control: Usual care |
N=21 adults with CF (intervention: n=15, control: n=6) Mean (SD) age: intervention: 21.8 (3.6); control: 23.0 (5.7) All study participants fulfilled the criteria for commencement of enteral tube feeding (CF Trust, 2002): BMI<19 kg/m2 and/or 5% acute weight loss over a 2 month period with a failure or oral nutritional supplements to adequately improve nutritional status.
|
| Initially n=17 accepted enteral tube feeding. However 2 people died during the baseline year and subsequent analyses were conducted on the surviving participants. Control group: people who declined enteral tube feeding Follow-up: 1 year Population was considered as direct. |