Table 205Clinical evidence summary: manual therapy (soft tissue technique - massage) + self-management (exercise prescription) versus Postural therapy (Alexander technique - 24 lessons) for low back pain without sciatica

OutcomesNo of Participants
(studies)
Follow up
Quality of the evidence
(GRADE)
Anticipated absolute effects
Risk with ControlRisk difference with Soft tissue technique + self-management (exercise prescription) versus Alexander technique (24 lessons)
(95% CI)
Quality of life (SF-36 physical component summary score, 0-100) >4 months117
(1 study)
1 year
LOWa,b
due to risk of bias, imprecision
The mean Quality of life (SF-36 physical component summary score, 0-100) >4 months in the control groups was
67.93
The mean Quality of life (SF-36 physical component summary score, 0-100) >4 months in the intervention groups was
8.47 lower
(17.15 lower to 0.21 higher)
Quality of life (SF-36 mental component summary score, 0-100) >4 months117
(1 study)
1 year
MODERATEa
due to risk of bias
The mean Quality of life (SF-36 mental component summary score, 0-100) >4 months in the control groups was
68.54
The mean Quality of life (SF-36 mental component summary score, 0-100) >4 months in the intervention groups was
1.01 lower
(9.32 lower to 7.3 higher)
Pain severity (Von Korff pain scale, 0-10) >4 months118
(1 study)
1 year
LOWa,b
due to risk of bias, imprecision
The mean pain severity (von Korff pain scale) >4 months in the control groups was
3.4
The mean pain severity (von Korff pain scale) >4 months in the intervention groups was
0.68 higher
(0.28 lower to 1.64 higher)
Function (RMDQ, 0-24) >4 months117
(1 study)
1 year
LOWa,b
due to risk of bias, imprecision
The mean function (RMDQ) >4 months in the control groups was
5.09
The mean function (RMDQ) >4 months in the intervention groups was
1.77 higher
(0.11 lower to 3.65 higher)
Healthcare utilisation (primary care contacts) > 4 months117
(1 study)
1 year
MODERATEa
due to risk of bias
The mean Healthcare utilisation (primary care contacts) > 4 months in the control groups was
0.44
The mean Healthcare utilisation (primary care contacts) > 4 months in the intervention groups was
0.12 lower
(0.42 lower to 0.18 higher)
Healthcare utilisation (prescriptions) >4 months93
(1 study)
1 year
LOWa,b
due to risk of bias, imprecision
The mean Healthcare utilisation (prescriptions) >4 months in the control groups was
1.07
The mean Healthcare utilisation (prescriptions) >4 months in the intervention groups was
0.49 lower
(1.14 lower to 0.16 higher)
a

Downgraded by 1 increment if the majority of the evidence was at high risk of bias, and downgraded by 2 increments if the majority of the evidence was at very high risk of bias

b

Downgraded by 1 increment if the confidence interval crossed 1 MID or by 2 increments if the confidence interval crossed both MIDs.

From: 12, Manual therapies

Cover of Low Back Pain and Sciatica in Over 16s: Assessment and Management
Low Back Pain and Sciatica in Over 16s: Assessment and Management.
NICE Guideline, No. 59.
National Guideline Centre (UK).
Copyright © NICE, 2016.

NCBI Bookshelf. A service of the National Library of Medicine, National Institutes of Health.