Clinical Description
Ataxia is the main cause of disability in ataxia with oculomotor apraxia type 1 in the first stages of the disease. Later, peripheral axonal motor neuropathy dominates the clinical picture.
Cerebellar ataxia. Symptoms are first noticed between ages two and ten years (mean: 4.3 years). In about 50% of affected individuals, onset is before age seven years. Two Italian adults with cerebellar ataxia were reported having disease onset at ages 28 and 29 years [Criscuolo et al 2004].
After initial normal motor development, all individuals develop cerebellar ataxia. The first manifestations of AOA1 are slowly progressive gait imbalance followed by dysarthria, then upper-limb dysmetria with mild intention tremor.
Oculomotor apraxia. Oculomotor apraxia is present in all individuals with AOA1. It is usually noticed a few years after the onset of ataxia. Oculomotor apraxia is the most striking feature in this disorder, but can be missed on routine neurologic examination. Individuals with oculomotor apraxia do not fixate normally on objects. When asked to look to one side, they turn their heads first, with eye contraversion, after which their eyes follow to the same side in several slow saccades with head thrusts.
Blinking is exaggerated in most individuals.
Ocular movements on command are usually slightly limited; the eyes stop before reaching extreme positions of gaze. These slow eye movements appear equally on lateral and vertical gaze.
When the head is immobilized, movement of the eyes is impossible.
Oculocephalic reflexes are spared until advanced stages of the disease. When standing and turning their heads, affected individuals lose their balance and tend to move the whole body to compensate.
Ocular pursuit movements remain normal during the first years after the appearance of oculomotor apraxia. Later, oculomotor apraxia is followed by progressive external ophthalmoplegia (beginning with upward gaze).
Neuropathy. All individuals with AOA1 have an axonal peripheral neuropathy, with early areflexia that dominates the clinical picture in advanced phases of the disease and is the major cause of motor disability with severe weakness and wasting. Loss of independent walking happens about seven to ten years after onset; most individuals become wheelchair bound by adolescence.
Hands and feet are short and atrophic. Pes cavus is present in 30% of individuals and scoliosis in a few.
Vibration and postural sense are impaired only in older individuals with very long disease duration. Pain and light touch sensation are preserved.
Chorea. About 45% of affected individuals have chorea even after a long disease duration (≤51 years) [Shimazaki et al 2002, Le Ber et al 2003, Sekijima et al 2003, Tranchant et al 2003, Criscuolo et al 2004, Habeck et al 2004]. At onset, the percentage may be as high as 80%, but in almost 50% of affected individuals, chorea disappears over the course of the disease [Le Ber et al 2003].
Dystonia. Upper-limb dystonia occurs in about 50% of individuals and may in some cases be sufficiently pronounced to justify diagnostic consideration of extrapyramidal disorders.
Intellect. Different degrees of cognitive impairment are observed, largely independent of ethnic origin [Tachi et al 2000, Moreira et al 2001a, Shimazaki et al 2002, Le Ber et al 2003, Sekijima et al 2003, Criscuolo et al 2004, Quinzii et al 2005]. Severe cognitive disability was reported in a single family [Moreira et al 2001b].
Life span. In the Portuguese kindreds, the age at last examination ranged from 17 to 68 years, corresponding to a disease duration of 12 to 58 years (mean: 27.5 years); two individuals died, one of an unknown cause and the other, a girl age 11 years with AOA1 who had been symptomatic for eight years, from a thalamic tumor. One Japanese individual died at age 71 years. In the cohort reported by Le Ber et al [2003], disease duration was 51 years.
Other. No signs of extraneurologic involvement are evident.
Genotype-Phenotype Correlations
APTX pathogenic missense variants may be associated with a later onset (age ~9 years). All other individuals with AOA1 with homozygous truncating variants (nonsense or frameshift) had onset ranging between ages two and 12 years (mean: 4.6 years) [Moreira et al 2001b, Shimazaki et al 2002, Le Ber et al 2003, Sekijima et al 2003, Amouri et al 2004, Habeck et al 2004, Quinzii et al 2005].
Cognitive impairment was reported in several families of different ethnic origins who had a range of variant types, including nonsense, frameshift, splice site, and missense [Tachi et al 2000, Barbot et al 2001, Moreira et al 2001a, Shimazaki et al 2002, Le Ber et al 2003, Sekijima et al 2003, Criscuolo et al 2004, Quinzii et al 2005].
• The p.Trp279Ter nonsense variant can be associated with cognitive impairment [Le Ber et al 2003] or normal cognitive development [Moreira et al 2001a, Le Ber et al 2003, Tranchant et al 2003].
• The presence of severe cognitive impairment in p.[Glu232GlyfsTer38]+[Pro206Leu] compound heterozygotes and the presence of mild cognitive impairment/borderline intelligence in the respective homozygotes is unexplained.
Two compound heterozygotes for the p.Arg199His missense variant and an unidentified second pathogenic variant had an atypical presentation with marked dystonia and mask-like faces in addition to the AOA1 clinical picture.
The pathogenic variant p.Ala198Val is associated with predominant, more severe and persistent chorea [Le Ber et al 2003].
In two Italian adults, homozygous p.Pro206Leu and p.His201Gln pathogenic variants were associated with late-onset AOA1 (ages 28 and 29 years). In contrast, in Japanese individuals with AOA1, the p.Pro206Leu pathogenic variant is associated with earlier onset (age 10 years).
The pathogenic missense variant p.Pro206Leu is associated with a later onset [Date et al 2001] and the pathogenic variants p.Val263Gly and p.Lys197Gln with even later onset: age 15 years [Tranchant et al 2003] and 25 years [Date et al 2001] respectively.
To the authors' knowledge, no correlation exists between a specific pathogenic variant and the affected individual's survival.
Prevalence
Through a systematic population-based survey of hereditary ataxias being conducted in Portugal since 1993 [Silva et al 1997], Friedreich ataxia (as expected) was the most frequent autosomal recessive ataxia (32.8%), followed by AOA (12.6%). In Portugal there are now 42 individuals with AOA in 20 different families (AOA1= 3.6% of all autosomal recessive ataxias; AOA2= 3.3%). AOA prevalence in Portugal is estimated at 0.41 per 100,000 inhabitants. However, 20 of these individuals with AOA from 13 different families do not have either AOA1 or AOA2, illustrating AOA genetic heterogeneity [Bras et al 2015].
In Japan, AOA1 appears to be the most frequent cause of autosomal recessive ataxia [Uekawa et al 1992, Fukuhara et al 1995, Hanihara et al 1995, Kubota et al 1995, Sekijima et al 1998, Tachi et al 2000, Moreira et al 2001a, Shimazaki et al 2002, Sekijima et al 2003]. In the entire cohort studied by Le Ber et al [2003] mostly individuals of French origin with progressive cerebellar ataxia in whom Friedreich ataxia had been excluded — the frequency of AOA1 was 5.7%; among the subset of individuals with onset before age 25 years, the frequency of AOA1 was 9.1%.
Affected individuals with pathogenic variants in APTX have been identified worldwide: thirteen individuals from three unrelated Tunisian families [Amouri et al 2004]; two unrelated individuals from Germany [Habeck et al 2004]; three unrelated Italian individuals [Criscuolo et al 2004]; two American children [Tsao & Paulson 2005]; and four individuals of northern European ancestry with ataxia and CoQ10 deficiency [Quinzii et al 2005].