U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government

NCBI Bookshelf. A service of the National Library of Medicine, National Institutes of Health.

Wade R, Rice S, Llewellyn A, et al. Interventions for hyperhidrosis in secondary care: a systematic review and value-of-information analysis. Southampton (UK): NIHR Journals Library; 2017 Dec. (Health Technology Assessment, No. 21.80.)

Cover of Interventions for hyperhidrosis in secondary care: a systematic review and value-of-information analysis

Interventions for hyperhidrosis in secondary care: a systematic review and value-of-information analysis.

Show details

Appendix 3Studies excluded at full-paper stage with rationale

Study detailsReason for exclusion
Abrams and Hallett 2013360Not a SR or primary prospective study
Adar et al. 1977361Not a SR or primary prospective study
Aguilar-Ferrandiz et al. 2011283Not relevant comparator (psychological techniques)
Ak et al. 2013362No intervention
Ak et al. 2013363No intervention
Aksu et al. 2011281Not a SR or primary prospective study
Alvarez et al. 2013231Not a SR or primary prospective study
Alvarez et al. 2013224Not a SR or primary prospective study
Ambrogi et al. 2009272Not relevant comparator (sympathectomy)
Amini et al. 2008217Not a SR or primary prospective study
Amir et al. 2000186No intervention
Andrade et al. 2012208Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Andrews and Rennie 1997364Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Anonymous 2004365Not a SR or primary prospective study
Araujo et al. 2009366Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Atkinson et al. 2010367Not a SR or primary prospective study
Attia and Salah 2011219Not relevant intervention (photodynamic therapy)
Awad et al. 2010368Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Aydemir and Toh 2006369Not relevant intervention (comparison of specific techniques)
Bachmann et al. 2009317Not a SR or primary prospective study
Bandeira et al. 2009370Not a SR or primary prospective study
Basra et al. 2008275Not primary hyperhidrosis
Baumgartner and Toh 2003371Not a SR or primary prospective study
Baumgartner et al. 2009372Not a comparative study (treatments undertaken sequentially)
Bechaux 2009373Not a SR or primary prospective study
Bell et al. 2014374Not a SR or primary prospective study
Benohanian et al. 1998375Not relevant intervention (aluminium chloride)
Birnie and Motley 2009268Not a SR or primary prospective study
Bischof et al. 2005376Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Bisseriex et al. 2012377Not primary hyperhidrosis
Boas 2000378Not a SR or primary prospective study
Boley et al. 2007319Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Bryan et al. 2012379Not a SR or primary prospective study
Bygstad et al. 2013380Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Cameron and Ojimba 2004381Not a SR or primary prospective study
Cardoso et al. 2009320Not a SR or primary prospective study
Cerfolio et al. 201115Not a SR or primary prospective study
Chan et al. 2007321Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Chen et al. 1996382Not a SR or primary prospective study
Chen et al. 2001383Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Chen et al. 2013384Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Cheng et al. 2015334Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Chia et al. 2012385Not relevant intervention (glycopyrronium bromide iontophoresis)
Cho et al. 1994386Not relevant comparator (aluminium chloride and sympathectomy)
Cinà and Clase 1999292No intervention
Clerico et al. 2014387Not a SR or primary prospective study
Coelho et al. 2014388Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Copleymerriman et al. 2015389Not primary hyperhidrosis
Coveliers et al. 2011215Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Currie et al. 2011322Not a SR or primary prospective study
Davarian et al. 2008264Not relevant intervention (BTX iontophoresis vs. saline)
de Campos et al. 2003238Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
de Campos et al. 2005390Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Delaplace et al. 2015211Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Deng et al. 2011391Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Dickmann and Dickmann 20102Not a SR or primary prospective study
Divisi et al. 2013323Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Doolabh et al. 2004392Not a SR or primary prospective study
Dressler et al. 2002393Not relevant intervention (comparing different doses of BTX)
Drott et al. 1995394Not a SR or primary prospective study
Drott and Claes 1996395Not a SR or primary prospective study
Duarte et al. 2003396Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Dumont et al. 1997397Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Ebrahim 2011398Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Edmondson et al. 1992399Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Elia et al. 2005299Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Ellis 1977400Not a SR or primary prospective study
Ellis and Scurr 1979401Not relevant intervention (aluminium chloride)
Ellis 1982402Not a SR or primary prospective study
Farahmand and Toolabi 2011403Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Fatemi Naeini et al. 2015404Not a SR or primary prospective study
Flanagan et al. 2008218Not relevant comparator (aluminium chloride)
Flørenes 2003405Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Flores 2012335Not a SR or primary prospective study
Fuentes et al. 2012207Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Furlan et al. 2000406Not primary hyperhidrosis
Galati and Raposio 2010407Not a SR or primary prospective study
Garcia Franco et al. 2011210Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Geddoa et al. 2008267Not a SR or primary prospective study
George et al. 2014408Not a SR or primary prospective study
Ghisletta et al. 1999409Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Gibbons et al. 2014274Not a SR or primary prospective study (CEA)
Glent-Madsen and Dahl 1988410Not primary hyperhidrosis
Goh 1990411Not relevant intervention (aluminium chloride)
Goh and Yoyong 1996412Not relevant comparator (tannic acid)
Goh et al. 2000413Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Goldman 2000414Not a SR or primary prospective study
Gorouhi et al. 2009220Not relevant comparator (aluminium chloride)
Gossot et al. 2001415Not a SR or primary prospective study
Grabham et al. 1998416Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Gracia et al. 2011324Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Greenhalgh et al. 1971417Not a SR or primary prospective study
Grimalt et al. 2006418Not relevant intervention (atropine)
Grootens and Hartong 2011419Not primary hyperhidrosis
Guérin et al. 1990420Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Hasche et al. 1997156Duplicate report of Hasche et al. 1997156
Hashmonai 2011421Not a SR or primary prospective study
Hecht et al. 2004422Not relevant intervention (comparing different doses of BTX)
Heidemann and Licht 2013423Not a SR or primary prospective study
Hekmat et al. 2010297Not a SR or primary prospective study
Henriques et al. 2014424Not a SR or primary prospective study
Henteleff and Kalavrouziotis 2008425Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Hoorens and Ongenae 2012426Not a SR or primary prospective study
Hornberger et al. 2004189Not a SR or primary prospective study
Hsu et al. 1998427Not a SR or primary prospective study
Ibrahim et al. 2013245Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Ibrahim et al. 2013428Not a SR or primary prospective study
Innocenzi et al. 2008429Not relevant intervention (aluminium sesquichlorhydrate foam)
Ishy et al. 2011239Not dermatology study: Ssympathectomy
Isla-Tajera et al. 2013230Not a dermatology study: quality of life/economics only
Ismail and El Samadoni 2015213Not a SR or primary prospective study
Jaffer et al. 2007336Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Jani 2009430Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Jeganathan et al. 2008325Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Jog et al. 2010431Not primary hyperhidrosis
Kamudoni et al. 2012204No intervention
Kamudoni et al. 2014228No intervention
Kamudoni et al. 2015261No intervention
Kavanagh et al. 2004432Not a SR or primary prospective study
Kavanagh and Shams 2006433Not relevant intervention (BTX iontophoresis vs. saline)
Khademi Kalantari et al. 2011434Not relevant intervention (aluminium chloride)
Kim et al. 2005435Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Kim et al. 200818Not a SR or primary prospective study
Kim et al. 2008436Not primary hyperhidrosis
Kopelman et al. 1996437Not a SR or primary prospective study
Koskinen et al. 2012308Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Kravarusic and Freud 2012438Not a SR or primary prospective study
Krogstad et al. 2006439No intervention
Kuijpers et al. 2013282Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Kumar et al. 2014440Not a SR or primary prospective study
Kuo et al. 2004259No intervention
Lakraj et al. 2013441Not a SR or primary prospective study
Lau et al. 2014442Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Law and Ellis 1989443Not a SR or primary prospective study
Lawrence and Lonsdale Eccles 2006444Not a SR or primary prospective study
Leão et al. 2003445Not a SR or primary prospective study
Lecouflet et al. 2014446Not a SR or primary prospective study
Lee et al. 2004447Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Lee and Ryman 2005448Not a SR or primary prospective study
Lee et al. 2006449Not primary hyperhidrosis
Lee et al. 2008450Not a SR or primary prospective study
Lessa et al. 2014284No intervention
Lewis et al. 1998451Not a SR or primary prospective study
Li et al. 201222Not primary hyperhidrosis
Licht and Pilegaard 2004452Not a SR or primary prospective study
Lin and Fang 1999453Not a SR or primary prospective study
Lin et al. 2000454Not a SR or primary prospective study
Lin 2001455Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Little 2004456Not a SR or primary prospective study
Lladó et al. 2005457Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Loureiro et al. 2008246Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Lupin and Hong 2012209Duplicate report Lupin et al. 2011175
Malmivaara et al. 2007458Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Malone et al. 1986459Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Marcella et al. 2011221Not a SR or primary prospective study
Masters and Rennie 1992460Not a SR or primary prospective study
McAleer et al. 2009265Not a SR or primary prospective study
Mehrotra et al. 2014229Not a SR or primary prospective study
Menna et al. 2012461Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Micali et al. 2013266Not relevant intervention (aluminium chloride)
Misiak et al. 2012462Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Montaser-Kouhsari et al. 2014463Not relevant intervention (BTX iontophoresis)
Mordant et al. 2010464Not a SR or primary prospective study
Moya et al. 2006465Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Muhammad and Allam 2014466Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Muller and Augustin 2013340Not dermatology study: quality of life/economics only
Munia et al. 2007328Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Munia et al. 2008327Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Nakamura et al. 2008467Not a SR or primary prospective study
Naumann and Hamm 2002468Not a SR or primary prospective study
Neidhardt et al. 2010469Not a SR or primary prospective study
Neumayer et al. 2003470Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Neumayer et al. 2005471Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Neumayer et al. 2005257Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Neves et al. 2012247Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Nicholson et al. 1994472Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Nieuwenhuis 2015473Not a SR or primary prospective study
Odderson 1998474Not a SR or primary prospective study
Ojimba and Cameron 2004475Not a SR or primary prospective study
Oncel et al. 2012476Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Panhofer et al. 2005233Not a SR or primary prospective study
Panhofer et al. 2006248Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Panhofer et al. 2011242Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Panhofer et al. 2013249Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Panhofer et al. 2013241Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Panhofer et al. 2014240Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Pastorelli and Plasmati 2013214Not relevant intervention (comparison of BTX brands)
Pastorelli et al. 2014223Not relevant intervention (comparison of BTX brands)
Paul et al. 2010273Not relevant intervention (effect of laser hair removal on effectiveness of BTX)
Penna et al. 2007477No effectiveness or quality-of-life outcome
Phadke et al. 1995478Not relevant comparator (topical methenamide and glutaraldehyde)
Ponce-Olivera et al. 2014479Not a SR or primary prospective study
Prasad et al. 2010250Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Purtuloglu et al. 2013480Not a SR or primary prospective study
Purtuloglu et al. 2013481Not a SR or primary prospective study
Raja and Campbell 2000482Not a SR or primary prospective study
Rameshkannan et al. 2010269Not relevant intervention (clonidine vs. propranolol)
Ramos et al. 2006483Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Ramos et al. 2007484Not a SR or primary prospective study
Ramos et al. 2009485Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Ramos et al. 2012486Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Ramsaroop et al. 2004487Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Rantanen and Telaranta 2013313Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Rathinam et al. 2008329Not a SR or primary prospective study
Rayner et al. 1980488Not relevant intervention (aluminium chloride)
Rezai 2009489Not a SR or primary prospective study
Rezende and Luz 2014490Not a SR or primary prospective study
Rieger and Pedevilla 2007491Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Rieger et al. 200917Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Rieger et al. 2011492Not a SR or primary prospective study
Rieger et al. 2015251Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Roddy 2012493Not a SR or primary prospective study
Rodriguez et al. 2008300Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Rodriguez-Lopez et al. 2010494Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Rzany et al. 2012227Not a dermatology study: quality of life/economics only
Saadia et al. 2001495Not relevant intervention (comparison of BTX doses)
Salek et al. 2015260Not primary hyperhidrosis
Sanli et al. 2010216Not a SR or primary prospective study
Scheer et al. 2014271Not a SR or primary prospective study
Scheer et al. 2014270Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Schestatsky et al. 2009496Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Scholes et al. 1978497Not relevant intervention (aluminium chloride)
Sciuchetti et al. 2008498Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Shalaby et al. 2012330Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Sharpe et al. 2013222Not a SR or primary prospective study
Shen et al. 1990499Not relevant intervention (aluminium chloride iontophoresis vs. tap water)
Shi et al. 2015331Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Simonyi et al. 2010500Not primary hyperhidrosis
Simonyi et al. 2010303Not a SR or primary prospective study
Simonyi et al. 2011304Not a SR or primary prospective study
Solish et al. 200712Not a SR or primary prospective study
Solish 2008501Not a SR or primary prospective study
Stefaniak et al. 2009502Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Stefaniak and Ćwigoń 2013503Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Stefaniak and Ćwigoń 2013504Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Steiner et al. 2007332Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Streker et al. 2010505Not relevant intervention (aluminium chloride)
Streker et al. 2012506Not relevant intervention (aluminium chloride)
Strutton et al. 2004226No intervention
Suh et al. 2014507Not a SR or primary prospective study
Swaile et al. 2012508Not primary hyperhidrosis
Swinehart 2000509Not a SR or primary prospective study
Tan and Solish 2002263Not a SR or primary prospective study
Tang et al. 2013510Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Teivelis et al. 2014253Not a SR or primary prospective study
Toolabi et al. 2015511Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Umezawa et al. 2011512Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Ureña et al. 2009513Not a SR or primary prospective study
Van Schil 2005514Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Vazquez et al. 2011305Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Vorkamp et al. 2010515Not a SR or primary prospective study
Wein et al. 2010516Not primary hyperhidrosis
Weiss et al. 2010517Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Wollina et al. 2002146Not relevant intervention (comparing different doses of BTX)
Wollina and Konrad 2004518Not a SR or primary prospective study
Wollina et al. 200820Not a SR or primary prospective study
Wolosker et al. 2007519Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Wolosker et al. 2010244Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Wolosker et al. 2010234Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Wolosker et al. 2012252Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Wolosker et al. 2013254Not a SR or primary prospective study
Wolosker et al. 2013243Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Wolosker et al. 2014237Not a SR or primary prospective study
Wolosker et al. 2015255Duplicate report of Wolosker et al. 201567
Woolery-Lloyd and Valins 2009520Not a SR or primary prospective study
Woolery-Lloyd and Valins 2009521Not a SR or primary prospective study
Wörle et al. 2007522Not a SR or primary prospective study
Xiao et al. 2015333Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Yanagishita et al. 2012523Not relevant intervention (aluminium chloride)
Yazbek et al. 2005235Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Yazbek et al. 2009236Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Young et al. 2003298Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Youssef and Soliman 2015524Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Yuncu et al. 2013212Not dermatology study: sympathectomy
Zaba et al. 2013525Not relevant comparator (aluminium chloride and sodium chloride)
Zackrisson et al. 2008526Not relevant intervention (comparing different doses of BTX)

SR, systematic review.

Copyright © Queen’s Printer and Controller of HMSO 2017. This work was produced by Wade et al. under the terms of a commissioning contract issued by the Secretary of State for Health. This issue may be freely reproduced for the purposes of private research and study and extracts (or indeed, the full report) may be included in professional journals provided that suitable acknowledgement is made and the reproduction is not associated with any form of advertising. Applications for commercial reproduction should be addressed to: NIHR Journals Library, National Institute for Health Research, Evaluation, Trials and Studies Coordinating Centre, Alpha House, University of Southampton Science Park, Southampton SO16 7NS, UK.
Bookshelf ID: NBK470654

Views

  • PubReader
  • Print View
  • Cite this Page
  • PDF version of this title (2.9M)

Other titles in this collection

Recent Activity

Your browsing activity is empty.

Activity recording is turned off.

Turn recording back on

See more...