U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government

NCBI Bookshelf. A service of the National Library of Medicine, National Institutes of Health.

National Guideline Alliance (UK). Evidence reviews for the investigation, management and follow-up of meningioma: Brain tumours (primary) and brain metastases in adults: Evidence Report B. London: National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE); 2018 Jul. (NICE Guideline, No. 99.)

Cover of Evidence reviews for the investigation, management and follow-up of meningioma

Evidence reviews for the investigation, management and follow-up of meningioma: Brain tumours (primary) and brain metastases in adults: Evidence Report B.

Show details

Appendix LResearch recommendations

R5. Is immediate or deferred radiotherapy better for incompletely excised grade I meningioma?

Why is this important?

There are no randomised studies on the use of radiotherapy/radiosurgery in the treatment of grade I meningioma. Though case series have shown that people with inoperable and incompletely excised grade I meningioma treated with radiotherapy have high rates of control of their tumour, treatment risks significant side effects. The side effects include: neuropathy, radionecrosis, significant oedema, neuro-cognitive effects, increased risk of stroke and secondary tumours. Therefore the timing of treatment is a balance between control of tumour and side effects. It is not known if early treatment has a greater or lesser chance of long-term tumour control or risk of tumour complications, or if this just risks complications of treatment earlier.

People with grade I meningioma have traditionally been overlooked as a priority area for research. This is likely because of the slow nature of the disease resulting in need for long-term follow up and the difficulty to obtain funding for radiotherapy-only studies. However, this lack of research is inequitable, hence the reason for its prioritisation by the committee.

A study on this topic would provide clear information to guide clinicians and people with meningiomas, hopefully leading to overall improvement in quality of life. Because of the slow-growing characteristics of grade I meningioma, treatment decisions made early in the management pathway will have long-term effects on the person with the meningioma’s overall quality of life outcomes, and potentially overall survival.

Table 38Research recommendation rationale

Research questionIs immediate or deferred radiotherapy better for incompletely excised grade I meningioma?
Importance to ‘patients’ or the populationCurrently treatment recommendations are based on case series only. For people with meningioma treatment of the condition is a balance between side effects of treatment, complications of tumour growth and rate of control of the tumour. From the case series it is unclear if it is better to treat meningioma immediately or only on progression of the tumour/tumour symptoms.
Relevance to NICE guidanceHigh Priority: Recommendations are extremely complex but based on clinical consensus. It may be that a strong trial in this area could simplify recommendations across subgroups.
Relevance to NHSEnsuring the people with meningioma receive the best treatment to result in optimal outcomes is important to the NHS, especially as there is large variation in different areas.
National prioritiesThis research is supportive of NHS England’s Cancer Strategy Implementation Plan, since it supports the development of a modern radiotherapy service.
Current evidence baseThere is some evidence where cohorts have had either immediate radiotherapy or deferred radiotherapy, which could in principle be synthesised to produce low-quality evidence on this research question, but there is no direct evidence on this topic of high importance. The EORTC trial attempted to answer a question similar to this, but could not recruit due to lack of equipoise. However radiotherapy techniques have improved significantly since then, and so the committee believed that a trial would be possible now.
EqualityN/A

Table 39Research recommendation PICO

PopulationAdults (18 years onwards) with an incompletely excised or inoperable grade I meningioma
InterventionImmediate radiotherapy, understood to usually mean sterotactic radiotherapy/radiosurgery to the residual depending on clinical characteristics
ComparisonDeferred radiotherapy (given on clinical or radiological progression), understood to usually mean sterotactic radiotherapy/radiosurgery to the residual depending on clinical characteristics
Outcomes
  • Quality of life
  • Neurocognitive decline
  • Overall survival
  • Progression-free survival
  • Local control
  • Radiation Therapy Oncology Group toxicity
Study designRandomised controlled trial
Timeframe10-year follow up
Copyright © NICE 2018.
Bookshelf ID: NBK570023

Views

  • PubReader
  • Print View
  • Cite this Page
  • PDF version of this title (4.0M)

Other titles in this collection

Recent Activity

Your browsing activity is empty.

Activity recording is turned off.

Turn recording back on

See more...