Clinical Description
Ornithine transcarbamylase (OTC) deficiency can occur as a severe neonatal-onset disease in males and as a post-neonatal-onset (also known as "late-onset" or partial deficiency) disease in males and females. Neonatal-onset disease in females is rare.
While neonatal-onset OTC deficiency accounted for approximately 60% of all OTC deficiency in the older literature, in its first eight years the longitudinal study of the Urea Cycle Disorders Consortium (UCDC) of the NICHD-supported Rare Disease Clinical Research Network (RDCRN) had enrolled a substantially smaller proportion of individuals with neonatal-onset OTC deficiency than with post-neonatal-onset OTC deficiency. Of 260 individuals who had symptomatic OTC deficiency, 47 (18%) had neonatal-onset disease (42 males and 5 females) and 213 (82%) had post-neonatal onset disease (154 females and 59 males) [Batshaw et al 2014]. This discrepancy may be the result of an ascertainment bias both in the older literature (in which undiagnosed individuals with milder symptoms are presumably underrepresented) as well as in the natural history study data, where individuals with very severe neonatal-onset OTC deficiency who die before study enrollment are underrepresented.
Neonatal-Onset OTC Deficiency
Males with severe OTC deficiency are asymptomatic at birth, but become symptomatic from hyperammonemia in the first week of life (most often on day 2-3) with poor suck, reduced intake, and hypotonia, followed by lethargy progressing to somnolence and coma. They hyperventilate, and may have subclinical/electroencephalographic seizures. By the time neonates with OTC deficiency come to medical attention they typically are catastrophically ill with low body temperature (hypothermia), severe encephalopathy, and respiratory alkalosis.
When clinical and laboratory findings support the diagnosis of a urea cycle disorder, rescue therapy is begun immediately (see Management, Treatment of Manifestations).
The prognosis of a newborn in hyperammonemic coma depends on the duration of elevated ammonia level, not the height of the ammonia level or the presence/absence of seizures [Msall et al 1984].
After successful rescue from neonatal hyperammonemic coma, infants with severe neonatal-onset OTC deficiency can easily become hyperammonemic again despite a low-protein diet and treatment with an oral ammonia scavenger. Even on maximum ammonia scavenger therapy a neonate with severe OTC deficiency may only tolerate 1.5 g/kg/day of protein (the minimum amount needed to grow), and growth may be along the third percentile for length.
After neonatal rescue therapy, a child with severe neonatal-onset disease can also experience a "honeymoon" period in which the protein tolerance is so high, due to rapid growth, that the child is metabolically stable for some months before experiencing frequent hyperammonemic episodes.
Typically, a liver transplant is required to prevent life-threatening hyperammonemic episodes, avert the effect of recurrent hyperammonemia on the brain, and improve quality of life.
The overall outcome depends on the severity of brain damage during the initial hyperammonemic crisis and during subsequent hyperammonemic crises, as well as on the success of long-term treatment in maintaining metabolic balance and addressing complications of the disease.
Post-Neonatal-Onset (Partial) OTC Deficiency
Hemizygous males and heterozygous females with partial OTC deficiency can present from infancy to later childhood, adolescence, or adulthood [Ahrens et al 1996, Ausems et al 1997, McCullough et al 2000]. Often, they first become symptomatic in infancy when switched from breast milk to formula or whole milk (breast milk contains less protein than infant formulas manufactured in the US). Infants may show episodic vomiting, lethargy, irritability, failure to thrive, and developmental delay. They show true protein avoidance, which can be documented by a detailed assessment of their dietary intake. If forced to eat foods high in protein, they may become symptomatic.
When children, adolescents, or adults with post-neonatal-onset disease become encephalopathic they may reach Stage 2 coma [Posner et al 2019] with erratic behavior, combativeness, and delirium (e.g., failure to recognize family members around them, unintelligible speech). They may come to medical attention if these behavior abnormalities lead to an emergency medical or psychiatric evaluation.
A stressor can cause an individual with partial OTC deficiency to become symptomatic at any age. In general, the milder the disease, the later the onset and the stronger the stressor required to precipitate symptoms.
Adults with very mild disease have become symptomatic after crush injury, following surgery [Chiong et al 2007, Hu et al 2007], when on a high-protein diet (e.g., Atkins diet [Ben-Ari et al 2010]), during the postpartum period (see Pregnancy Management), during cancer therapy, after prolonged fasting [Marcus et al 2008], when treated with high-dose systemic corticosteroids [Lipskind et al 2011], or after a febrile illness [Panlaqui et al 2008]. Treatment with valproate [Arn et al 1990, Honeycutt et al 1992, Leão 1995, Oechsner et al 1998, Thakur et al 2006] or haloperidol [Rubenstein et al 1990] has been associated with hyperammonemic crises in persons with OTC deficiency.
Heterozygous Females
The phenotype of a heterozygous female can range from asymptomatic to significant symptoms with recurrent hyperammonemia and neurologic compromise depending on favorable vs nonfavorable X-chromosome inactivation. The amount of OTC enzyme activity in the liver of a heterozygous female depends on the pattern of X-chromosome inactivation in her liver [Yorifuji et al 1998]. Thus, a heterozygous female can manifest symptoms of OTC deficiency if X-chromosome inactivation in her liver cells is skewed such that the X chromosome with the pathogenic OTC variant is active in more hepatocytes than the X chromosome with the normal OTC allele [McCullough et al 2000, Yamaguchi et al 2006].
Previously, approximately 15% of heterozygous females were thought to become symptomatic during their lifetime [Batshaw et al 1986]. Many heterozygous females exhibit mild symptoms, self-restrict protein intake, and are never diagnosed as being symptomatic. The diagnosis may only be revealed when a more severely affected child is born, prompting molecular genetic testing in the mother. Thus, the percent of symptomatic females may be higher than previously thought. When a male has post-neonatal-onset disease, the risk for symptoms in heterozygous females in his family is much lower than in families in which a male has neonatal-onset severe disease [McCullough et al 2000].
Recent work suggests that some heterozygous females may be paucisymptomatic: while they may never have hyperammonemia or present with altered mental status, they may in fact have differences in cognitive capability, such as deficits in executive functioning and motor capability [Sprouse et al 2014, Anderson et al 2020].
Complications of Neonatal-Onset and Post-Neonatal-Onset Disease
Neuropsychological. Typical neuropsychological complications include: developmental delay; learning disabilities; intellectual disability; attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD); deficits in executive function, working memory, visuo-motor integration, and visual perception [Waisbren et al 2015, Buerger et al 2019]; and emotional and behavioral problems [Waisbren et al 2015]. Scores in cognitive domains were not independent; in fact, in one study they were found to closely correlate with intelligence scores [Waisbren et al 2016, Buerger et al 2019]. Intelligence scores also correlated with peak ammonia level and with number of hyperammonemic episodes [Buerger et al 2019, Posset et al 2019] which are also indicators of the severity of disease. Subjects with neonatal-onset disease have higher peak ammonia levels and lower scores on intellectual tests than those with post-neonatal-onset disease [Buerger et al 2019].
Attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder and executive function deficits can greatly affect (school) performance even when intellectual ability is in the normal range [
Krivitzky et al 2009].
Approximately half of school-age children with OTC deficiency were reported by their parents as having "internalizing problems" on the Child Behavior Checklist, including being withdrawn, depressed, and/or anxious, or having somatic complaints.
Impulsivity and immaturity can lead to inappropriate behavior and problems in peer relationships especially for preteens and adolescents.
Self-reported difficulties in social relationships, as well as anxiety and depression, have also been described in adults with OTC deficiency, including those who are "asymptomatic" [
Waisbren et al 2016]. This may lead to problems in interpersonal relationships and frequent job changes.
Even heterozygous females who have never had biochemical evidence of hyperammonemia and therefore were thought to be asymptomatic, on further scrutiny have been shown to have mild cognitive impairments and deficits in executive function and fine motor tasks even when exhibiting normal IQ on neuropsychological testing. These deficits may be apparent only when these individuals are cognitively challenged [Sprouse et al 2014, Anderson et al 2020].
Neurologic. During hyperammonemic coma, electroencephalogram (EEG) shows low voltage with slow waves and may include a burst suppression pattern in which the duration of the interburst interval correlates with the height of the ammonia levels Seizures are common during hyperammonemic coma and may only be detected on EEG. They do not indicate a poor prognosis. However, persons with urea cycle disorders may also be prone to having seizures independent of hyperammonemic episodes [Zecavati et al 2008, Wiwattanadittakul et al 2018].
Neuroimaging studies show hyperintense signal in the peri-insular region; in severe disease, a progression of restricted diffusion from the peri-insular region to first frontal, then parietal, temporal, and ultimately the occipital lobes may be apparent. In extremis, restricted diffusion was also observed in the thalami [Bireley et al 2012]. Neonates who survived after prolonged coma may have ventriculomegaly, diffuse brain atrophy (not affecting the cerebellum), low-density white matter defects, and injury to the bilateral lentiform nuclei and the deep sulci of the insular and perirolandic regions [Yamanouchi et al 2002, Takanashi et al 2003].
Although metabolic strokes (involving the caudate and putamen and resulting in extrapyramidal syndromes) have been described in OTC deficiency and CPS1 deficiency [Keegan et al 2003, Takanashi et al 2003], they are not typical for urea cycle disorders.
Neuropathology in those children who died after prolonged coma included cortical atrophy with ventriculomegaly, prominent cortical neuronal loss, and spongiform changes at the gray-white interface and in the basal ganglia and thalamus [Dolman et al 1988].
Better neurologic outcomes are seen in infants with neonatal-onset disease who were treated soon after the onset of coma.
Gastrointestinal
During a hyperammonemic crisis liver enzymes are typically moderately elevated and PT and PTT may be prolonged.
Severe elevations of liver enzyme and coagulopathy consistent with acute liver failure are more typically seen in individuals with OTC deficiency after the neonatal period [
Mustafa & Clarke 2006].
Prolonged PT and PTT as well as mildly increased direct bilirubin are also observed in persons with a urea cycle disorder during long-term follow up when ammonia levels are normal and the individual is asymptomatic.
Symptomatic individuals with urea cycle disorders are at risk of developing progressive growth impairment over time. Weight is not affected. Growth impairment has recently been shown to be possibly associated with reduced or borderline plasma branched-chain amino acid concentrations. Liver transplant appears to have a beneficial effect on linear growth [
Posset et al 2020].
Liver cell carcinoma has been described in a few older individuals (e.g., in a symptomatic heterozygous female age 66 years [Wilson et al 2012]), suggesting that OTC deficiency may be associated with an increased risk for liver cancer. However, data are insufficient to support such a conclusion.
Prevalence
OTC deficiency is thought to be the most common urea cycle defect (see Urea Cycle Disorders Overview).
An early estimated prevalence of OTC deficiency was 1:14,000 live births [Brusilow & Maestri 1996]. However, other surveys of incidence of OTC deficiency in Italy, Finland, and New South Wales, Australia, have revealed a lower prevalence of 1:70,000, 1:62,000, and 1:77,000 live births, respectively [Dionisi-Vici et al 2002, Keskinen et al 2008, Balasubramaniam et al 2010]. Given that males and females with partial OTC deficiency may manifest symptoms at any age, prevalence numbers are biased toward the earliest and most severe presentations.