Clinical Description
ARSACS (autosomal recessive spastic ataxia of Charlevoix-Saguenay) defines a spastic ataxia first described in 1978 among a cohort of about 325 French-Canadian individuals from 200 families born in the Saguenay-Lac-St-Jean area of northeastern Quebec [Bouchard et al 1978]. The disorder has since been identified in other areas of the world (see Prevalence). Most individuals display a slowly progressive course of unsteadiness, often with onset before age ten years (usually of late-infantile onset) and associated with spasticity during childhood and neuropathy during teenage years.
In addition to the classic triad of symptoms of progressive cerebellar ataxia, peripheral neuropathy, and lower-limb spasticity, some individuals with ARSACS have features such as hearing loss, intellectual disability, and myoclonic epilepsy [Breckpot et al 2008, McMillan et al 2009, Terracciano et al 2009, Ali et al 2016, Nascimento et al 2016, Briand et al 2019]. Furthermore, absence of one of the three defining clinical features has been described in several individuals [Shimazaki et al 2005, Shimazaki et al 2007, Baets et al 2010, Synofzik et al 2013, Vill et al 2018, Rezende Filho et al 2019].
Both intra- and interfamilial phenotypic variability has been observed in ARSACS.
To date, more than 190 individuals have been identified with biallelic pathogenic variants in SACS [Vermeer at al 2008, Baets et al 2010, Synofzik et al 2013, Pilliod et al 2015, Vill et al 2018, Rezende Filho et al 2019] (LOVD3 Database). The following table of the phenotypic features associated with this condition is based on the table in the publication of Pilliod et al [2015]. Note: Not all features were measured in the different groups of affected individuals; some relative frequencies are less representative due to a lower total number of individuals measured.
Table 2.
View in own window
Organ System | Feature | % of Persons with Feature |
---|
Neurologic
| Ataxia, kinetic | 96% (135/140) 1-6 |
Ataxia, static | 95% (140/146) 1-6 |
Cognitive decline | 5% (3/51) 1, 3 |
Dysarthria | 74% (37/50) (at age 18 yrs) 2 |
Dysphagia | 13% (11/84) 3, 5, 6 |
Dystonia | 7% (5/70) 3, 6 |
Epilepsy | 7% (5/70) 3, 6 |
Extension plantar response | 86% (119/138) 1-5 |
Linear hypointensities pons (FLAIR) on brain MRI | 49% (19/39) 3 |
Nystagmus | 74% (89/120) 1-5 |
Sensorimotor polyneuropathy | 97% (36/37) (axonal 25%; demyelinating 53%; both 14%) 3 |
Vermis atrophy w/upper predominance on brain MRI | 83% (39/47) 3 |
Neuromuscular/
Developmental
| Muscle wasting, lower limb | 51% (28/54) 3, 4 |
Muscle wasting, upper limb | 19% (8/43) 3, 4 |
Spasticity, lower limb | 75% (77/103) 1-6 |
Spasticity, upper limb | 15% (9/58) 1-6 |
Stiff legs, isolated, at disease onset | 5% 3 |
Unsteadiness at disease onset | 96% (43/45) (isolated 82%; w/stiff legs 11%) 3 |
Weakness, lower limb | 60% (74/124) 1-5 |
Weakness, upper limb | 3% (21/60) 1-5 |
Wheelchair bound after age 30 yrs | 25% (6/24) 3 |
Ophthalmologic
| Hypertrophy of retinal myelinated fibers | 33% (19/58) 1, 3-6 |
Hearing
| Hearing loss | 13% (8/62) 1, 4 |
Other
| Intellectual disability / school difficulties | 29% (28/95) 1-3 |
Pes cavus
| 61% (75/123) 1-3 |
Scoliosis | 15% (9/62) 3, 4 |
Urinary dysfunction | 34% (38/111) 1-6 |
Onset and progression. The mean age at onset is approximately six years (range: 0-40 years) [Vermeer et al 2008, Baets et al 2010, Duquette et al 2013, Prodi et al 2013, Synofzik et al 2013, Pilliod et al 2015].
Most individuals show the highly characteristic triad of cerebellar ataxia, peripheral neuropathy, and pyramidal tract signs [Ogawa et al 2004, Vermeer et al 2008, Baets et al 2010, Duquette et al 2013, Prodi et al 2013, Synofzik et al 2013, Pilliod et al 2015]. The first signs of the disease are a slowly progressive cerebellar ataxia (which can lead to delayed walking because of gait unsteadiness in very young infants [Bouchard et al 1978]) usually with subsequent lower-limb spasticity, followed by features of peripheral neuropathy. However, pronounced peripheral neuropathy as a first sign of ARSACS, followed by pyramidal and cerebellar signs, has also been observed [Synofzik et al 2013]. Often, this leads to significant and severe lower-limb and gait impairment.
Neurologic findings. A childhood-onset mixed sensorimotor peripheral neuropathy with both axonal and demyelinating features is observed in most affected individuals. This leads to distal muscle atrophy and weakness, foot deformities, impaired tactile and vibration sense, and (eventually) a decrease in or loss of tendon reflexes in the legs [Vermeer et al 2008].
Distal amyotrophy, which leads to loss of ankle reflexes and sometimes bilateral foot drop, is found in most individuals after age 21 years. Other deep tendon reflexes may remain brisk or disappear with time.
Oculomotor disturbances (nystagmus), dysarthria, and upper-limb ataxia usually progress much slower than gait ataxia, spasticity, and neuropathy.
Dysarthria, one of the features associated with cerebellar dysfunction, usually appears in late childhood and is slowly progressive.
Brain imaging. Findings include atrophy of the superior vermis and the cerebellar hemisphere, linear hypointense stripes in the paramedian pons, a hyperintense lateral pons where merging into the cerebellar peduncles, thickened middle cerebellar peduncles [Synofzik et al 2013], and hyperintense rim around the thalami [Oguz et al 2013, Kuchay et al 2019]. However, some individuals with ARSACS are reported to display no abnormalities on brain MRI. This notion has to be interpreted with caution, however, as even some of the published cases with allegedly none of these MRI signs show hyperintense stripes in the pons on closer inspection [Vill et al 2018].
Cognitive skills. Difficulties in school performance are reported, in some cases due to mild intellectual disability. ARSACS is not associated with severe intellectual disability.
The extent to which cognitive impairment is a feature of ARSACS is still unclear and is being studied.
Hearing loss has been described in a minority of affected individuals; it is not known whether this is a true feature of ARSACS . The type of hearing loss in most cases has not been described; Breckpot et al [2008] described bilateral sensorineural hearing loss in a person age 26 years with ARSACS involving a large deletion on chromosome 13q12.12. Of note in this individual, the brain auditory evoked potentials on the left were abnormal whereas those on the right side were normal.
Urinary dysfunction. Urinary urgency and incontinence, mainly due to pyramidal tract dysfunction, can be present.
Atypical neurologic phenotype. Three individuals with biallelic pathogenic variants in SACS and an unusual phenotype (lacking either spasticity or peripheral neuropathy) have been described [Shimazaki et al 2005, Baets et al 2010]. However, the two affected individuals described by Shimazaki et al with absence of lower-limb spasticity both displayed bilateral Babinski signs indicating pyramidal involvement; here, the spasticity was likely masked by the severe neuropathy. In the third individual, from a Belgian cohort, clinical or electrophysiologic signs of peripheral neuropathy were lacking. Disease onset in this individual was unusually late (age 40 yrs); it may be that peripheral neuropathy had not yet developed. Unfortunately, this individual was lost to further follow up.
Vill et al [2018] described nine individuals who were clinically diagnosed with hereditary motor and sensory neuropathy (HMSN) and harbored biallelic pathogenic variants in SACS. None of these individuals displayed spasticity or pyramidal signs and only three displayed ataxia, which was considered to be a sensory ataxia [Vill et al 2018]. However, on closer inspection, eight of the nine individuals were found to have either cerebellar oculomotor disturbances and/or cerebellar atrophy (specifically of the vermis).
Ophthalmologic findings. A characteristic retinal finding is the presence of yellow streaks of hypermyelinated fibers radiating from the edges of the optic disc.
Retinal nerve fiber hypertrophy as demonstrated on ocular coherence tomography has been reported in several individuals with ARSACS [Pablo et al 2011, Kuchay et al 2019], but is not present in all affected individuals.
A thicker-than-119-µm average peripapillary retinal nerve fibre layer provides a sensitivity of 100% and specificity of 99.4% in individuals with ARSACS [Parkinson et al 2018].
These ocular findings do not have an impact on vision in most affected individuals, though the oldest individuals with ARSACS may have visual impairment.
Cardiac findings. Mitral valve prolapse was described as a frequent feature among individuals with ARSACS from Quebec [Bouchard et al 1978]. To date it has been reported in only one affected individual not of Quebec origin [Baets et al 2010]. One affected individual developed severe enlarged cardiomyopathy [Synofzik, unpublished observation], but whether the cardiomyopathy is related to the presence of pathogenic variants in SACS has not been determined. At this stage, as cardiac abnormalities are apparently not a frequent part of the phenotype of ARSACS overall, a special workup on a routine basis does not appear to be required.
Life span. The only study to date that reported on life expectancy in those with ARSACS concluded that it was shortened on average to 51 years [Dupré et al 2006].