Byrne 1998 (7) | Streptomycin Gentamicin Ciprofloxacin Ofloxacin (Others) | Animal: female mice. Challenge: Y. pestis CO92 delivered by aerosol → PP; and SC → BP. Intervention: streptomycin, gentamicin (12 or 20 mg/kg), ciprofloxacin, ofloxacin or other antibiotic not addressed in this review, IP, every 6 hours for 5 days:
- -
early treatment, initiated 24 hours post-challenge exposure - -
late treatment, initiated 42 hours post-challenge exposure.
Control: normal saline.Cohort size: 15–20 (usually 20). | Main outcome: death/survival up to 14 days after starting treatment:
- -
CFR for PP, early treatment:
- -
streptomycin: 0/20 (0%) - -
gentamicin: 8/40 (20%) for 12 mg/kg dose; 4/20 (20%) for 20 mg/kg dose - -
ciprofloxacin: 0/35 (0%) - -
ofloxacin: 0/20 (0%)
- -
CFR for PP, late treatment:
- -
streptomycin: 35/85 (41%) - -
gentamicin: 26/38 (68%) for 12 mg/kg dose; 3/20 (15%) for 20 mg/kg dose - -
ciprofloxacin: 17/45 (38%) - -
ofloxacin: 8/20 (40%)
- -
CFR for BP treated with streptomycin:
- -
24 hours post-challenge exposure: 0/20 (0%) - -
42 hours post-challenge exposure: 6/20 (30%) - -
48 hours post-challenge exposure: 15/20 (75%) - -
54 hours post-challenge exposure: 11/20 (55%).
|
Gur 2018 (8) | Gentamicin Tobramycin (Combinations) | Animal: female outbred mice. Challenge: intranasal fully virulent Y. pestis Kimberley53 strain (Kim53) → PP. Intervention: initiated 24 and 48 hours post-challenge exposure, for 5 days:
- -
gentamicin (3.5 mg/kg per day), by inhalation; or - -
gentamicin (3.5 mg/kg per day), SC; or - -
tobramycin (1.5 mg/kg per day), by inhalation.
Combinations of antibiotics, not summarized for the purpose of this review.Control: untreated. Cohort size: 8 per cohort. | Main outcome: death/survival up to 16 days after starting treatment. CFR:
- -
when started 24 hours post-challenge exposure, simulating PEPT:
- -
gentamicin, by inhalation: 0/8 (0%); 1/8 (13%) for increased Y. pestis infection dose - -
gentamicin, SC: 5/8 (60%); 6/8 (75%) for increased Y. pestis infection dose - -
tobramycin, by inhalation: 0/8 (0%) - -
control: 8/8 (100%).
- -
when started 48 hours post-challenge exposure:
- -
gentamicin, by inhalation: 0/8 (0%) - -
gentamicin, SC: 8/8 (100%) - -
control: 8/8 (100%).
|
Heine 2007 (9) | Gentamicin Doxycycline Levofloxacin | Animal: female BALB/c neutropenic (N) and non-neutropenic (nonN) mice. Challenge: Y. pestis CO92 delivered by aerosol → PP. Cohort size: 10 mice. Intervention: levofloxacin (15 mg/kg every 12 hours) or doxycycline (40 mg/kg every 6 hours) or gentamicin (12 mg/kg every 6 hours or 24 mg/kg every 12 hours or 48 mg/kg every 24 hours), IP, initiated 24 hours post-challenge exposure, for 5 days. Control: placebo with saline. | Main outcome: death/survival up to 21 days after starting treatment. CFR:
- -
levofloxacin: nonN 0%; N 0%; control 100% - -
doxycycline: nonN 10%; N 100%; control 100% - -
gentamicin: nonN 10% (12 mg/kg every 6 hours), 0% (24 mg/kg every 12 hours) and 20% (48 mg/kg every 24 hours); N 30%, 20% and 20%, respectively; control 100%.
|
Heine 2014 (10) | Ciprofloxacin (Imipenem) (Ceftazidime) | Animal: female BALB/c mice. Challenge: Y. pestis CO92 delivered by aerosol → PP. Intervention: ciprofloxacin (30 mg/kg every 12 hours) or imipenem (data not collected for this review) or ceftazidime (data not collected for this review), IP, initiated 24 hours (PEPT experiment) and 42 hours post-challenge exposure (treatment experiment), for 5 days. Cohort size: 10 mice in the ciprofloxacin cohort. Control: 0.85% saline. | Main outcome: death/survival up to 21 days after starting treatment. CFR:
- -
ciprofloxacin as PEPT: 0% - -
ciprofloxacin as treatment: 50%.
|
Petersen 2010 (11) | Levofloxacin | Animal: Swiss-Webster mice. Challenge: Y. pestis CO92 by nasal instillation → PP. Intervention: levofloxacin at various doses from 0.1 to 15 mg/kg per day, IP, initiated 24, 36 or 48 hours post-challenge exposure for 6 days. Control: no antibiotics. Cohort size: not reported. | Main outcome: death/survival at 20 days post-challenge exposure. CFR:
- -
when started 24 hours post-challenge exposure:
- -
5, 10 or 15 mg/kg: 0% died - -
1 mg/kg: 20% died - -
0.5 or 0.1 mg/kg: 100% died
- -
when started 36 hours post-challenge exposure: 5 or 10 mg/kg: 10% died - -
when started 48 hours post-challenge exposure:
- -
10 mg/kg: 80% died - -
5 mg/kg: 90% died
|
Rahalison 2000 (12) | Streptomycin Chloramphenicol | Animal: female OF1 mice. Challenge: virulent Y. pestis strain 6/69 IV → SP. Intervention: initiated 24 hours post-challenge exposure:
- -
streptomycin (30 mg/kg every 8 hours), SC, for 2, 3 or 4 days; or - -
chloramphenicol (100 mg/kg every 8 hours), IM, for 2, 3 or 4 days; or - -
OCm (100 mg/kg or 200 mg/kg per dose), IM, as a single injection at 24 hours post-challenge exposure; or - -
OCm (200 mg/kg per dose), IM, as two injections at 24 and 48 hours post-challenge exposure.
Control: physiological saline, IM or SC.Cohort size: 5. | Main outcome: death/survival at 15 days post-challenge exposure. CFR:
- -
streptomycin, SC: 1/5 (20%), 0/5 (0%) and 0/5 (0%) after 2, 3 and 4 days of treatment, respectively - -
chloramphenicol, IM: 1/5 (20%) after 4 days of treatment (no results given for 2 and 3 days) - -
OCm, IM, single injection:
- -
100 mg/kg: 7/10 (70%) - -
200 mg/kg: 5/5 (100%)
- -
OCm, IM, two injections: 3/5 (60%).
|
Rosenzweig 2011 (13) | Levofloxacin (Cethromycin) | Animal: female Brown Norway rats. Challenge: Y. pestis CO92 by intranasal inoculation at day 0, and at day 43 or 34 → PP PP. Intervention: levofloxacin at various doses from 0.5 to 15 mg/kg per day, IP, or 20 mg/kg per day, orally, initiated 24 hours post-challenge exposure, for 6 days. Delayed start at 36, 42 and 48 hours post-challenge exposure with doses of 5 and 10 mg/kg per day, IP, for 6 days. Control: phosphate-buffered saline. Cohort size: 6 rats per group for treatment started at 24 hours, 9 rats per group for delayed treatment and control. | Main outcome: death/survival at 42 and 60 days post-challenge exposure for those with antibiotic treatment initiated 24 hours post-challenge exposure; death/survival at 33 and 65 days post-challenge exposure for those with delayed treatment. CFR:
- -
when started 24 hours post-challenge exposure:
- -
15 mg/kg: 0/6 (0%) and 2/6 (33%) at 42 and 60 days, respectively - -
10 mg/kg: 0/6 (0%) at 42 and 60 days - -
5 mg/kg: 2/6 (33%) at 42 and 60 days - -
1 mg/kg: 5/6 (83%) at 42 and 60 days - -
0.5 mg/kg: 6/6 (100%) at 42 days - -
control: 9/9 (100%) at 42 days.
- -
CFR for delayed treatment:
- -
at 24, 36 and 42 hours post-challenge exposure, for 10 or 5 mg/kg: 0/9 (0%) at 34 days - -
at 48 hours post-challenge exposure for 10 or 5 mg/kg: 6/9 (66%) at day 34.
|
Russell 1996 (14) | Doxycycline Ciprofloxacin | Animal: Porton outbred mice. Challenge: IP Y. pestis strain GB with 5 or 6 challenge doses → SP. Intervention:
- -
ciprofloxacin, SC, 40 or 20 mg/kg every 12 hours, administered from 48 hours pre-challenge exposure to 5 days post-challenge exposure, or - -
ciprofloxacin, SC, 40 or 20 mg/kg every 12 hours, initiated 24 hours post-challenge exposure, for 5 days, or - -
doxycycline, SC, 40 or 20 mg/kg every 12 hours, administered from 48 hours pre-challenge exposure to 4 days post-challenge exposure, or - -
doxycycline, SC, 40 or 20 mg/kg every 12 hours, initiated 24 hours post-challenge exposure, for 4 days.
Control: no antibiotics.Cohort size: 30 mice for each dose cohort of ciprofloxacin, 25 mice for each dose cohort of doxycycline, 10 mice untreated. | Main outcome: death/survival up to 20 days post-challenge exposure. CFR:
- -
ciprofloxacin as pre-exposure prophylaxis: 0/30 (0%) for each dose - -
ciprofloxacin as PEPT: 14/30 (46.7%) for each dose - -
doxycycline as pre-exposure prophylaxis: 15/25 (60%) for 40 mg/kg dose, 24/25 (96%) for 20 mg/kg dose - -
doxycycline as PEPT: 23/25 (92%) for 40 mg/kg dose, 25/25 (100%) for 20 mg/kg dose.
|
Russell 1998 (15) | Doxycycline Ciprofloxacin | Animal: Porton outbred mice. Challenge: Y. pestis strain GB and strain CO92 delivered by aerosol → PP. Intervention: ciprofloxacin or doxycycline given at 40 mg/kg every 12 hours, SC, in one of the four regimens:
- -
prophylaxis: administered from 48 hours pre-challenge exposure to 5 days post-challenge exposure - -
initiated immediately post-challenge exposure, for 5 days - -
initiated 24 hours post-challenge exposure, for 5 days - -
initiated 48 hours post-challenge exposure, for 5 days.
Control: not specified if placebo or untreated.Cohort size: not reported. | Main outcome: death/survival up to 20 days post-challenge exposure. CFR for both Y. pestis strains:
- -
doxycycline 100%; ciprofloxacin 0% - -
doxycycline 100%; ciprofloxacin 0% - -
doxycycline 90% and 100% for GB and CO92 strains, respectively; ciprofloxacin 0% - -
doxycycline 100%; ciprofloxacin 100%.
Controls: 100% for all regimens. |
Steenbergen 2017 (16) | Omadacycline Doxycycline Ciprofloxacin | Animal: female BALB/c mice. Challenge: Y. pestis CO92 delivered by aerosol → PP. Intervention: omadacycline (5, 10, 20 or 40 mg/kg every 12 hours) or doxycycline (5, 10, 20 or 40 mg/kg every 12 hours) or ciprofloxacin (15 mg/kg every 12 hours), IP, initiated 1 hour post-challenge exposure, for 7 days. Control: saline (0.2 mL every 12 hours), IP, for 7 days. Cohort size: 10 mice. | Main outcome: death/survival up to 38 to 41 days after starting treatment. CFR:
- -
omadacycline: 10% (40 mg/kg), 0% (other doses) - -
doxycycline: 10% (40 mg/kg), 0% (other doses) - -
ciprofloxacin: 0%.
|
Steward 2004 (17) | Ciprofloxacin Gatifloxacin Moxifloxacin | Animal: female BALB/c inbred mice. Challenge: Y. pestis strain GB delivered SC and by aerosol → SP and PP. Intervention: ciprofloxacin, gatifloxacin or moxifloxacin: 2 mg every 12 hours, orally, for 7 days:
- -
systemic challenge (SP): initiated 1 hour pre-challenge exposure, or 6, 18 or 24 hours post-challenge exposure - -
aerosol challenge (PP): initiated 6, 18, 30 or 48 hours post-challenge exposure.
Control: deionized water.Cohort size: 18 mice per cohort; 252 mice for each of infection route. | Main outcome: death/survival up to 21 days after starting treatment. CFR:
- -
systemic challenge (SP):
- -
ciprofloxacin: 1 hour pre-challenge exposure: 0/18 (0%); 6 hours post-challenge exposure: 0/18 (0%); 18 hours post-challenge exposure: 3/18 (17%); 24 hours post-challenge exposure: 13/18 (72%); control: 18/18 (100%) - -
gatifloxacin: 1 hour pre-challenge exposure: 0/18 (0%); 6 hours post-challenge exposure: 0/18 (0%); 18 hours post-challenge exposure: 2/18 (11%); 24 hours post-challenge exposure: 5/18 (28%); control: 18/18 (100%) - -
moxifloxacin: 1 hour pre-challenge exposure: 0/18 (0%); 6 hours post-challenge exposure: 0/18 (0%); 18 hours post-challenge exposure: 8/18 (45%); 24 hours post-challenge exposure: 12/18 (67%); control: 18/18 (100%)
- -
aerosol challenge (PP):
- -
ciprofloxacin: 6, 18 and 30 hours post-challenge exposure: 0/18 (0%); 48 hours post-challenge exposure: 17/18 (94%); control: 18/18 (100%) - -
gatifloxacin: 6, 18 and 30 hours post-challenge exposure: 0/18 (0%); 48 hours post-challenge exposure: 12/18 (67%); control: 18/18 (100%) - -
moxifloxacin: 6, 18 and 30 hours post-challenge exposure: 0/18 (0%) each; 48 hours post-challenge exposure: 10/18 (56%); control: 18/18 (100%).
|