Evidence Table 1, Randomized Controlled Trials Evaluating the Self-Monitoring of Blood Glucose - Self-Monitoring of Blood Glucose in Patients with Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus

Warning: The NCBI web site requires JavaScript to function. more...

NCBI Bookshelf. A service of the National Library of Medicine, National Institutes of Health.

Shekelle P, Munjas B, Romanova M, et al. Self-Monitoring of Blood Glucose in Patients with Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus: Meta Analysis of Effectiveness [Internet]. Washington (DC): Department of Veterans Affairs (US); 2007 Sep.

Cover of Self-Monitoring of Blood Glucose in Patients with Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus

Self-Monitoring of Blood Glucose in Patients with Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus: Meta Analysis of Effectiveness [Internet].

Show details

Contents

Evidence Table 1Randomized Controlled Trials Evaluating the Self-Monitoring of Blood Glucose

Author, Year	Sample Size Enroll/ Follow-up	Dur. of Diabetes inYears	Mean Age	Mean Weight (kg) / BMI	% Women / Race	Delphi List Quality Criteria			Arm/Group					Outcome	Adverse Events
						Method of Randomization	Eligibility criteria specified	Point estimates & measures of variability for primary outcome variable	Sample Size entering	Components	# Visit	Freq of SMBG Times/ Week	Dur. of Tx
						Allocation Concealment	Outcome assessor blind
						Similarity at Baseline between groups	Care provider blind	Did analysis included intention to treat analysis
						Similarity at Baseline between groups	Patients blinded	Did analysis included intention to treat analysis
WingRR et al., 1986 ¹⁹	50 / 45	NR	54	98 / NR	78% / NR	Yes	Yes	Yes	25	Exercise Counseling/Edu	20	Control	62 wks	A1c Fasting Glucose BMI/Weight loss	ND
						No	No	No	25	SMBG Exercise Pt Control led Counseling/Edu	20	5.4	62 wks
						No	No
						No	No
Fontbonne A et al., 1989 ²⁰	208 / 164	13	55	73 / 27	42% / NR	No	Yes	Yes	68	Counseling/Edu	4	Control	6 mths	A1c BMI/Weight Loss	ND
						No	No	No	68	SMBG Counseling/Edu	4	7.5	6 mths
						Yes	No
						Yes	No
Rutten G et al., 1990 ²³	149 / 127	8.1	63	75 / NR	65% / NR	No	Yes	Yes	83	NR	NA	Control	1 year	A1c BMI/Weight Loss	ND
						No	No	No	66	SMBG Dietician Counseling/Edu	Variable	NR	1 year
						No	No
						No	No
Muchmore DB et al., 1994 ²⁴	29 / 23	5	59	99 / 34	61% / NR	Yes	Yes	Yes	14	Dietician Counseling/Edu	8	Control	44 wks	A1c BMI/Weight Loss HRQOL^*	ND
						No	No	Yes	15	SMBG Dietician Counseling/Edu	8	3	44 wks
						Yes	No
						Yes	No
Jaber LA et al., 1996 ²⁵	45 / 39	6	62	90 / 33	70% / African Ancestr y	No	Yes	Yes	22	NR	2	Control	4 mths	A1c Fasting Glucose HRQOL^*	Hypoglycemia
						No	No	No	23	SMBG Pt Controlled Counseling/Edu	NR	8	4 mths
						Yes	No
						Yes	No
Kibriya MG, et al., 1999 ²⁷	64 / 64	NR	50	60 / 24	45% / NR	No	Yes	Yes	32	Counseling/Edu	19	Control	18 mths	A1c Fasting Glucose	Hypoglycemia
						No	No	No	32	SMBG Pt Control led Counseling/Edu	7	1	18 mths
						No	No
						No	No
Schwedes U, et al., 2002 ²⁹	250 / 223	5.3	60	89 / 31	48% / NR	Yes	Yes	Yes	110⁺	Counseling/Edu	6	Control	24 wks	A1c BMI/Weight Loss HRQOL^*	ND
						No	No	No	113⁺	SMBG Dietician Counseling/Edu	6	12	24 wks
						Yes	No
						Yes	No
Guerci B, et al., 2003 ³⁰	988 / 689	8.1	62	83 / 30	45% / NR	No	Yes	Yes	344⁺	Counseling/Edu	5	Control	6 mths	A1c Fasting Glucose	Hypoglycemia Other
						No	No	Yes	345⁺	SMBG Counseling/Edu	5	6	6 mths
						Yes	No
						Yes	No
Davidson MB, et al., 2005 ³²	89 / 88	5.6	50	82.3 / 32.5	74% / African Ancestry, Hispanic, Other	No	Yes	Yes	45	Dietician Other	13	Control	6 mths	A1c BMI/Weight Loss	ND
						No	Yes	Yes	43	SMBG Dietician Other	13	36	6 mths
						Yes	Yes
						Yes	No
Farmer A et al., 2007³³	453 / 453	3	66	NR / 31.3	43% / NR	Yes	Yes	Yes	152	Usual Care	NR	Control	12 mths	A1c BMI/Weight Loss	Hypoglyceima
						Yes	No	Yes	150	SMBG	NR	6	12 mths
						Yes	No	Yes	151	SMBG Patient Control	NR	NR	12 mths
						Yes	No	Yes	151	SMBG Patient Control	NR	NR	12 mths

: ND=Not Described, NR=Not Reported, NA=Not applicable,
*: HRQOL=Health Related Quality of Life,
+: No entering sample size reported, this is the sample size completing the trial

From: APPENDIX C, EVIDENCE TABLE

Contents

Views

Cite this Page
Shekelle P, Munjas B, Romanova M, et al. Self-Monitoring of Blood Glucose in Patients with Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus: Meta Analysis of Effectiveness [Internet]. Washington (DC): Department of Veterans Affairs (US); 2007 Sep. Evidence Table 1, Randomized Controlled Trials Evaluating the Self-Monitoring of Blood Glucose.
PDF version of this title (678K)

Other titles in this collection

VA Evidence-based Synthesis Program Reports

Recent Activity

Clear Turn Off Turn On

Evidence Table 1, Randomized Controlled Trials Evaluating the Self-Monitoring of...
Evidence Table 1, Randomized Controlled Trials Evaluating the Self-Monitoring of Blood Glucose - Self-Monitoring of Blood Glucose in Patients with Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus

Your browsing activity is empty.

Activity recording is turned off.

Turn recording back on