U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government

NCBI Bookshelf. A service of the National Library of Medicine, National Institutes of Health.

Bonell C, Dickson K, Hinds K, et al. The effects of Positive Youth Development interventions on substance use, violence and inequalities: systematic review of theories of change, processes and outcomes. Southampton (UK): NIHR Journals Library; 2016 May. (Public Health Research, No. 4.5.)

Cover of The effects of Positive Youth Development interventions on substance use, violence and inequalities: systematic review of theories of change, processes and outcomes

The effects of Positive Youth Development interventions on substance use, violence and inequalities: systematic review of theories of change, processes and outcomes.

Show details

Appendix 9Theory studies: coding templates

BOX 1

NVivo Node Structure Report: Kate Hinds

Hierarchical name

Definition of PYD interventions
Definition of PYD interventions\Aspects of interventions

Definition of PYD interventions\Aspects of interventions\Age-related progression.

Definition of PYD interventions\Aspects of interventions\Developmental outcomes and related activities.

Definition of PYD interventions\Aspects of interventions\Interaction between activities and context.

Definition of PYD interventions\Aspects of interventions\Programme atmosphere.

Definition of PYD interventions\Aspects of interventions\Programme characteristics.

Definition of PYD interventions\Aspects of interventions\Programme characteristics\Multilevel, feedback loops, negotiation.

Definition of PYD interventions\Aspects of interventions\Structure of activities.

Definition of PYD interventions\Aspects of interventions\Structure of activities\Breadth of activities.

Definition of PYD interventions\Aspects of interventions\Structure of activities\Intensity.

Definition of PYD interventions\Aspects of interventions\Targeting vs. universal.

Definition of PYD interventions\Comparisons and integrations

Definition of PYD interventions\Comparisons and integrations\Comparison with deficit model.

Definition of PYD interventions\Comparisons and integrations\Comparison with traditional youth programmes.

Definition of PYD interventions\Comparisons and integrations\Integration between PYD and resilience.

Definition of PYD interventions\Comparisons and integrations\Prevention programmes.

Definition of PYD interventions\Comparisons and integrations\PYD vs. prevention interventions.

Definition of PYD interventions\Comparisons and integrations\Relationship between protective factors and developmental assets.

Definition of PYD interventions\Comparisons and integrations\Relationship between protective factors and developmental assets\Action of risk and protective factors.

Definition of PYD interventions\Comparisons and integrations\Relationship between risk-protection approach and applied developmental science.

Definition of PYD interventions\Comparisons and integrations\Treatment programmes.

Definition of PYD interventions\Components of PYD

Definition of PYD interventions\Components of PYD\Asset-building community.

Definition of PYD interventions\Components of PYD\Asset-building society.

Definition of PYD interventions\Components of PYD\Developmental assets.

Definition of PYD interventions\Components of PYD\Developmental assets\sixth C: contribution.

Definition of PYD interventions\Components of PYD\Developmental assets\sixth C: contribution\Contribution as link between individual and context.

Definition of PYD interventions\Components of PYD\Developmental assets\Connectedness.

Definition of PYD interventions\Components of PYD\Developmental assets\Thriving.

Definition of PYD interventions\Components of PYD\Developmental assets\Thriving\Self-regulation.

Definition of PYD interventions\Components of PYD\Domains.

Definition of PYD interventions\Components of PYD\Domains\Behavioural domain.

Definition of PYD interventions\Components of PYD\Domains\Cognitive domain.

Definition of PYD interventions\Components of PYD\Domains\Educational domain.

Definition of PYD interventions\Components of PYD\Domains\Emotional domain.

Definition of PYD interventions\Components of PYD\Domains\Moral domain.

Definition of PYD interventions\Components of PYD\Domains\Physiological domain.

Definition of PYD interventions\Components of PYD\Domains\Social domain.

Definition of PYD interventions\Components of PYD\Domains\Structural domain.

Definition of PYD interventions\Components of PYD\Notion of hope.

Definition of PYD interventions\Components of PYD\Notion of optimism.

Definition of PYD interventions\Developmental science

Definition of PYD interventions\Developmental Science\Associations in behavioural science.

Definition of PYD interventions\Developmental Science\Definitions.

Definition of PYD interventions\Developmental Science\Definitions\Thriving.

Definition of PYD interventions\Developmental Science\Developmental affordances.

Definition of PYD interventions\Developmental Science\Identity development.

Definition of PYD interventions\Developmental Science\Plasticity.

Definition of PYD interventions\Developmental Science\Resiliency.

Definition of PYD interventions\Developmental Science\Resiliency\Protective factors.

Definition of PYD interventions\Developmental Science\Role of developmental assets in developmental science.

Definition of PYD interventions\Developmental Science\Selection, optimisation and compensation.

Definition of PYD interventions\Developmental Science\Systems theory.

Definition of PYD interventions\Developmental Science\Systems theory\Cultural-ecological framework.

Definition of PYD interventions\Developmental Science\Systems theory\Developmental regulation.

Definition of PYD interventions\Developmental Science\Systems theory\intentionality.

Definition of PYD interventions\Developmental Science\Systems theory\Interaction between individual and their milieu.

Definition of PYD interventions\Developmental Science\Variation in developmental trajectories.

Mechanism of action
Mechanism of action\Action on risk

Mechanism of action\Action on risk\Action of protective factors.

Mechanism of action\Action on Thriving

Mechanism of action\Action on Thriving\Agency.

Mechanism of action\Action on Thriving\Developmental affordances.

Mechanism of action\Action on Thriving\Ecological modelling.

Mechanism of action\Action on Thriving\Group formation and group work.

Mechanism of action\Action on Thriving\identity development.

Mechanism of action\Action on Thriving\Interaction between individual and context.

Mechanism of action\Action on Thriving\Selection, optimisation and compensation.

Mechanism of action\Depth of participation
Mechanism of action\Importance of structured activities
Mechanism of action\Multilevel changes
Mechanism of action\Partnerships
Mechanism of action\Plasticity
Moderation by context

Moderation by context\Generalisability.

Moderation by context\Moderation by cultural background.

Moderation by context\Moderation by maturity.

Moderation by context\Moderation by risk.

Taxonomy
Taxonomy\Emphasis on adult relationships
Taxonomy\Programme variations responding to cultural difference
Taxonomy\Schools programmes
Taxonomy\Social action programmes

Taxonomy\Social action programmes\Programmes to address inequity.

BOX 2

NVivo Node Structure Report: Chris Bonell

Hierarchical name

Definition of PYD interventions
Definition of PYD interventions\Influences

Definition of PYD interventions\Influences\Developmental systems theory.

Definition of PYD interventions\Influences\Policy context of deficit thinking and erosion of traditional supports.

Definition of PYD interventions\Influences\Policy context of discovery of childhood and adolescence.

Definition of PYD interventions\Principles

Definition of PYD interventions\Principles\All young people have potential.

Definition of PYD interventions\Principles\PYD compensates for environmental deficits.

Definition of PYD interventions\Principles\PYD compensates for environmental deficits\But limits on this.

Definition of PYD interventions\Principles\PYD more than prevention

Definition of PYD interventions\Principles\PYD more than prevention\Problem free is not fully prepared.

Definition of PYD interventions\Principles\PYD more than prevention\PYD must enable strengths or thriving.

Definition of PYD interventions\Principles\PYD more than prevention\PYD must enable strengths or thriving\Expanded definition of health to include PYD assets.

Definition of PYD interventions\Principles\PYD more than prevention\PYD prevention may be compatible.

Definition of PYD interventions\Principles\PYD more than prevention\PYD prevention may be compatible\But not empirically established.

Definition of PYD interventions\Principles\PYD more than prevention\PYD prevention may be compatible\Counterargument that incompatible since prevention reinforces deficits.

Definition of PYD interventions\Principles\PYD more than prevention\PYD prevention may be compatible\Prevention model is not itself static.

Definition of PYD interventions\Principles\PYD more than prevention\PYD prevention may be compatible\Real programmes often combine prevention and promotion.

Definition of PYD interventions\What PYD must provide

Definition of PYD interventions\What PYD must provide\Overarching frameworks.

Definition of PYD interventions\What PYD must provide\Overarching frameworks\Goals, atmosphere and activities.

Definition of PYD interventions\What PYD must provide\Overarching frameworks\Goals, atmosphere and activities\Activities.

Definition of PYD interventions\What PYD must provide\Overarching frameworks\Goals, atmosphere and activities\Activities\Opportunities for real challenges, skills and new horizons.

Definition of PYD interventions\What PYD must provide\Overarching frameworks\Goals, atmosphere and activities\Atmosphere of hope.

Definition of PYD interventions\What PYD must provide\Overarching frameworks\Goals, atmosphere and activities\Atmosphere of hope\Atmosphere of hope (2).

Definition of PYD interventions\What PYD must provide\Overarching frameworks\Goals, atmosphere and activities\Atmosphere of hope\Elements of atmosphere of hope.

Definition of PYD interventions\What PYD must provide\Overarching frameworks\Goals, atmosphere and activities\Atmosphere of hope\Elements of atmosphere of hope\Empowerment.

Definition of PYD interventions\What PYD must provide\Overarching frameworks\Goals, atmosphere and activities\Atmosphere of hope\Elements of atmosphere of hope\Empowerment\Burt unclear how defined.

Definition of PYD interventions\What PYD must provide\Overarching frameworks\Goals, atmosphere and activities\Atmosphere of hope\Elements of atmosphere of hope\Empowerment\Burt unclear how defined\PYD as positive reinforcement, positive opportunities, positive norms.

Definition of PYD interventions\What PYD must provide\Overarching frameworks\Goals, atmosphere and activities\Atmosphere of hope\Elements of atmosphere of hope\Positive expectations.

Definition of PYD interventions\What PYD must provide\Overarching frameworks\Goals, atmosphere and activities\Goals = 5Cs (see below).

Definition of PYD interventions\What PYD must provide\Overarching frameworks\Goals, atmosphere and activities\Goals = 5Cs (see below)\PYD must address Cs other than just competence.

Definition of PYD interventions\What PYD must provide\Overarching frameworks\Skills plus participation plus caring adults.

Definition of PYD interventions\What PYD must provide\Overarching frameworks\Skills plus participation plus caring adults\Adults needs knowledge, observation, discipline, to support, have own support.

Definition of PYD interventions\What PYD must provide\Overarching frameworks\20 external assets PYD should offer.

Grouping (i.e. taxonomy)
Grouping (i.e. taxonomy\Explicit taxonomies)

Grouping (i.e. taxonomy)\Explicit taxonomies\Categorisation by breadth vs. depth.

Grouping (i.e. taxonomy)\Explicit taxonomies\Categorisation by how many of 5Cs they addressed.

Grouping (i.e. taxonomy)\Explicit taxonomies\Categorisation by type, duration, quality.

Grouping (i.e. taxonomy)\Explicit taxonomies\Categorisation by whether aim to prevent as well as promote.

Grouping (i.e. taxonomy)\Explicit taxonomies\Categorisation by whether modifies only individual or environment too.

Grouping (i.e. taxonomy)\Explicit taxonomies\Categorisation by whether modifies only individual or environment too\Debate as to whether should modify wider environments.

Grouping (i.e. taxonomy\Implicit taxonomies)

Grouping (i.e. taxonomy)\Implicit taxonomies\Challenge or accept societal arrangements.

Grouping (i.e. taxonomy)\Implicit taxonomies\Focus on group or individual attributes.

Mechanism of action
Mechanism of action\Assumptions i.e. bases

Mechanism of action\Assumptions i.e. bases\Individual-environment interactions.

Mechanism of action\Assumptions i.e. bases\Plasticity of development.

Mechanism of action\Assumptions i.e. bases\Plasticity of development\But one paper states strong genetic (presumably non-plastic) influence.

Mechanism of action\Key mechanisms

Mechanism of action\Key mechanisms\PYD enables developmental regulation.

Mechanism of action\Key mechanisms\PYD enables developmental regulation\Modifies intention self-regulation.

Mechanism of action\Key mechanisms\PYD enables developmental regulation\Modifies intention self-regulation\Selection, optimisation and compensation.

Mechanism of action\Key mechanisms\PYD enables developmental regulation\Modifies intention self-regulation\Selection, optimisation and compensation\Breadth and depth required former in early and latter in late adolescence.

Mechanism of action\Key mechanisms\PYD enables developmental regulation\Modifies intention self-regulation\Selection, optimisation and compensation\Breadth and depth required former in early and latter in late adolescence\Balance between these not clear.

Mechanism of action\Key mechanisms\PYD enables developmental regulation\Positive interactions between individual and environment.

Mechanism of action\Key mechanisms\PYD enables developmental regulation\Positive interactions between individual and environment\Positive feedback can ensue.

Mechanism of action\Key mechanisms\PYD enables developmental regulation\Positive interactions between individual and environment\Requires environmental not merely individual intervention.

Mechanism of action\Key mechanisms\PYD offers affordances in environment or developmental attentiveness.

Mechanism of action\Key mechanisms\PYD promotes identity development via exploration and commitment.

Mechanism of action\Key mechanisms\PYD promotes identity development via exploration and commitment\Erikson's theory of identity development in childhood and adolescence.

Mechanism of action\Key mechanisms\PYD promotes identity development via exploration and commitment\Linear and cyclic aspects.

Mechanism of action\Key mechanisms\PYD promotes identity development via exploration and commitment\Requires breadth and depth.

Mechanism of action\Key mechanisms\PYD reinforces bonding to conventional institutions.

Mechanism of action\Key PYD assets

Mechanism of action\Key PYD assets\PYD as promoting assets.

Mechanism of action\Key PYD assets\PYD as promoting assets\5Cs widely cited as key assets.

Mechanism of action\Key PYD assets\PYD as promoting assets\5Cs widely cited as key assets\Character.

Mechanism of action\Key PYD assets\PYD as promoting assets\5Cs widely cited as key assets\Competence.

Mechanism of action\Key PYD assets\PYD as promoting assets\5Cs widely cited as key assets\Confidence.

Mechanism of action\Key PYD assets\PYD as promoting assets\5Cs widely cited as key assets\Connections.

Mechanism of action\Key PYD assets\PYD as promoting assets\5Cs widely cited as key assets\Originally 4 Cs but caring (i.e. compassion) added.

Mechanism of action\Key PYD assets\PYD as promoting assets\Some studies cite other assets.

Mechanism of action\Key PYD assets\PYD as promoting assets\Some studies cite other assets\20 youth assets.

Mechanism of action\Key PYD assets\PYD as promoting assets\Some studies cite other assets\Commitment but may be covered by confidence in identity.

Mechanism of action\Key PYD assets\PYD as promoting assets\Some studies cite other assets\Critical thinking.

Mechanism of action\Key PYD assets\PYD as promoting assets\Some studies cite other assets\Critical thinking\Critical consciousness.

Mechanism of action\Key PYD assets\PYD as promoting assets\Some studies cite other assets\Critical thinking\Critical consciousness\3 stages: self-awareness, social awareness, global awareness.

Mechanism of action\Key PYD assets\PYD as promoting assets\Some studies cite other assets\Deficits in these function as risk factor for substance use.

Mechanism of action\Key PYD assets\PYD as promoting assets\Some studies cite other assets\Extra individual assets.

Mechanism of action\Key PYD assets\PYD as promoting assets\Some studies cite other assets\Extra individual assets\Community as well as individual assets.

Mechanism of action\Key PYD assets\PYD as promoting assets\Some studies cite other assets\Extra individual assets\Group as well as individual assets.

Mechanism of action\Key PYD assets\PYD as promoting assets\Some studies cite other assets\Learning to be productive, connect, navigate.

Mechanism of action\PYD distal products

Mechanism of action\PYD distal products\Contribution.

Mechanism of action\PYD distal products\Contribution\Behavioural and ideological components.

Mechanism of action\PYD distal products\Contribution\Rationale for this contribution.

Mechanism of action\PYD distal products\Domains of PYD impact.

Mechanism of action\PYD distal products\Horizontal and vertical pile up of assets (i.e. accumulation hypothesis).

Mechanism of action\PYD distal products\Horizontal and vertical pile up of assets (i.e. accumulation hypothesis)\Assets reduce risks in short term which determine longer term reductions.

Mechanism of action\PYD distal products\Molecular impacts (i.e. differentiation hypothesis).

Mechanism of action\Risk behaviours

Mechanism of action\Risk behaviours\Evidence cited that PYD does reduce risk.

Mechanism of action\Risk behaviours\Few papers describe mechanisms to risk.

Mechanism of action\Risk behaviours\Few papers describe mechanisms to risk\Accumulation hypothesis (i.e. horizontal and vertical pile-up).

Mechanism of action\Risk behaviours\Few papers describe mechanisms to risk\Differential hypothesis (i.e. molecular impacts).

Mechanism of action\Risk behaviours\Few papers describe mechanisms to risk\Differential hypothesis (i.e. molecular impacts)\Direct and indirect mechanisms.

Mechanism of action\Risk behaviours\Few papers describe mechanisms to risk\Differential hypothesis (i.e. molecular impacts)\Direct and indirect mechanisms\Bonding key asset which indirectly reduces problem behaviours via reducing association with delinquent peers.

Mechanism of action\Risk behaviours\Few papers describe mechanisms to risk\Differential hypothesis (i.e. molecular impacts)\Direct and indirect mechanisms\Positive expectations modify self-concept and behaviour directly.

Mechanism of action\Risk behaviours\Few papers describe mechanisms to risk\Differential hypothesis (i.e. molecular impacts)\Raises question of whether assets are protective factors.

Mechanism of action\Risk behaviours\Few papers describe mechanisms to risk\Differential hypothesis (i.e. molecular impacts)\Raises question of whether assets are protective factors\Assets are protective factors that also promote thriving.

Mechanism of action\Risk behaviours\Few papers describe mechanisms to risk\Differential hypothesis (i.e. molecular impacts)\Raises question of whether assets are protective factors\Assets are protective factors that also promote thriving\(e.g. relationship with adult reduces substance use).

Mechanism of action\Risk behaviours\Few papers describe mechanisms to risk\Differential hypothesis (i.e. molecular impacts)\Raises question of whether assets are protective factors\Assets are protective factors that also promote thriving\Some domains of impact are protective, deficits raise risk.

Mechanism of action\Risk behaviours\Few papers describe mechanisms to risk\Differential hypothesis (i.e. molecular impacts)\Raises question of whether assets are protective factors\Protective factors interact with risks but assets do not necessarily.

Mechanism of action\Risk behaviours\Few papers describe mechanisms to risk\Differential hypothesis (i.e. molecular impacts)\Raises question of whether assets are protective factors\PYD and risk could coexist.

Mechanism of action\Risk behaviours\Few papers describe mechanisms to risk\Differential hypothesis (i.e. molecular impacts)\Raises question of whether assets are protective factors\Two kinds of protection: buffering (interaction) and oppositional (not interaction).

Mechanism of action\Risk behaviours\Few papers describe mechanisms to risk\Identity hypothesis.

Mechanism of action\Risk behaviours\Few papers describe mechanisms to risk\Other theories fill gap.

Moderation by context
Moderation by context\By age
Moderation by context\By duration of relationship
Moderation by context\By programme features

Moderation by context\By programme features\More assets addressed, more effective the programme.

Moderation by context\High risk may overwhelm assets
Moderation by context\Mechanisms and assets may vary culturally

Moderation by context\Mechanisms and assets may vary culturally\But that framework itself is generalisable.

Moderation by context\Mechanisms and assets may vary culturally\But variation may not be addressed sufficiently in theories.

Moderation by context\Mechanisms and assets may vary culturally\e.g. in more group-based cultures.

Copyright © Queen’s Printer and Controller of HMSO 2016. This work was produced by Bonell et al. under the terms of a commissioning contract issued by the Secretary of State for Health. This issue may be freely reproduced for the purposes of private research and study and extracts (or indeed, the full report) may be included in professional journals provided that suitable acknowledgement is made and the reproduction is not associated with any form of advertising. Applications for commercial reproduction should be addressed to: NIHR Journals Library, National Institute for Health Research, Evaluation, Trials and Studies Coordinating Centre, Alpha House, University of Southampton Science Park, Southampton SO16 7NS, UK.

Included under terms of UK Non-commercial Government License.

Bookshelf ID: NBK362294

Views

  • PubReader
  • Print View
  • Cite this Page
  • PDF version of this title (7.6M)

Other titles in this collection

Recent Activity

Your browsing activity is empty.

Activity recording is turned off.

Turn recording back on

See more...