NCBI Bookshelf. A service of the National Library of Medicine, National Institutes of Health.
This publication is provided for historical reference only and the information may be out of date.
Structured Abstract
Objectives:
To review important patient safety practices for evidence of effectiveness, implementation, and adoption.
Data sources:
Searches of multiple computerized databases, gray literature, and the judgments of a 20-member panel of patient safety stakeholders.
Review methods:
The judgments of the stakeholders were used to prioritize patient safety practices for review, and to select which practices received in-depth reviews and which received brief reviews. In-depth reviews consisted of a formal literature search, usually of multiple databases, and included gray literature, where applicable. In-depth reviews assessed practices on the following domains:
- How important is the problem?
- What is the patient safety practice?
- Why should this practice work?
- What are the beneficial effects of the practice?
- What are the harms of the practice?
- How has the practice been implemented, and in what contexts?
- Are there any data about costs?
- Are there data about the effect of context on effectiveness?
We assessed individual studies for risk of bias using tools appropriate to specific study designs. We assessed the strength of evidence of effectiveness using a system developed for this project. Brief reviews had focused literature searches for focused questions. All practices were then summarized on the following domains: scope of the problem, strength of evidence for effectiveness, evidence on potential for harmful unintended consequences, estimate of costs, how much is known about implementation and how difficult the practice is to implement. Stakeholder judgment was then used to identify practices that were “strongly encouraged” for adoption, and those practices that were “encouraged” for adoption.
Results:
From an initial list of over 100 patient safety practices, the stakeholders identified 41 practices as a priority for this review: 18 in-depth reviews and 23 brief reviews. Of these, 20 practices had their strength of evidence of effectiveness rated as at least “moderate,” and 25 practices had at least “moderate” evidence of how to implement them. Ten practices were classified by the stakeholders as having sufficient evidence of effectiveness and implementation and should be “strongly encouraged” for adoption, and an additional 12 practices were classified as those that should be “encouraged” for adoption.
Conclusions:
The evidence supporting the effectiveness of many patient safety practices has improved substantially over the past decade. Evidence about implementation and context has also improved, but continues to lag behind evidence of effectiveness. Twenty-two patient safety practices are sufficiently well understood, and health care providers can consider adopting them now.
Contents
- Preface
- Authors and Affiliations
- Acknowledgments
- Additional Contributors
- Executive Summary
- Part 1. Overview
- Chapter 1. Introduction
- Chapter 2. Methods
- Topic Development
- Project Overview
- Topic Refinement
- Evidence Assessment Framework
- Evidence Review Process
- Assessing Quality of Individual Studies
- Assessing Strength of Evidence for a Patient Safety Practice
- Summarizing the Evidence
- Setting Priorities for Adoption of Patient Safety Practices
- Future Research Needs
- Peer and Public Review Process
- References
- Part 2. Evidence Reviews of Patient Safety Practices
- Part 2a. Practices Designed for a Specific Patient Safety Target
- Section A. Adverse Drug Events
- Chapter 3. High-Alert Drugs: Patient Safety Practices for Intravenous AnticoagulantsElizabeth Pfoh, MPH, David Thompson, DNSc, MS, RN, and Sydney Dy, MD, MSc.
- How Important Is the Problem?
- What Is the Patient Safety Practice?
- Why Should This Patient Safety Practice Work?
- What Are the Beneficial Effects of the Patient Safety Practice?
- What Are the Harms of the Patient Safety Practice?
- How Has the Patient Safety Practice Been Implemented, and in What Contexts?
- Are There Any Data About Costs?
- Are There Any Data About the Effect of Context on Effectiveness?
- Conclusions and Comment
- References
- Chapter 4. Clinical Pharmacist's Role in Preventing Adverse Drug Events: Brief Update ReviewPeter Glassman, MBBS, MSc.
- Chapter 5. The Joint Commission's “Do Not Use” List: Brief Review (NEW)Peter Glassman, MBBS, MSc.
- Chapter 6. Smart Pumps and Other Protocols for Infusion Pumps: Brief Review (NEW)James Reston, PhD, MPH.
- Chapter 3. High-Alert Drugs: Patient Safety Practices for Intravenous Anticoagulants
- Section B. Infection Control
- Chapter 7. Barrier Precautions, Patient Isolation, and Routine Surveillance for Prevention of Health Care-Associated Infections: Brief Update ReviewMarin Schweizer, PhD.
- Chapter 8. Interventions To Improve Hand Hygiene Compliance: Brief Update ReviewElizabeth Pfoh, MPH, Sydney Dy, MD, MSc, and Cyrus Engineer, DrPH.
- Chapter 9. Reducing Unnecessary Urinary Catheter Use and Other Strategies To Prevent Catheter-Associated Urinary Tract Infections: Brief Update ReviewJennifer Meddings, MD, MSc, Sarah L Krein, PhD, RN, Mohamad G Fakih, MD, MPH, Russell N Olmsted, MPH, CIC, and Sanjay Saint, MD, MPH.
- Introduction
- What Strategies May Prevent Catheter-Associated Urinary Tract Infections?
- What Strategies May Reduce Unnecessary Catheter Use?
- What Is the Impact of Strategies To Avoid Unnecessary Urinary Catheter Use?
- What Is the Cost of Implementing a CAUTI Prevention Program?
- What Methods Have Been Used To Improve the Implementation of Interventions To Prevent Catheter-Associated Urinary Tract Infections?
- Monitoring and Providing Feedback on Catheter Use and CAUTI Rates
- Conclusions and Comment
- References
- Chapter 10. Prevention of Central Line-Associated Bloodstream Infections: Brief Update ReviewVineet Chopra, MD, MSc, Sarah L Krein, PhD, RN, Russell N Olmsted, MPH, CIC, Nasia Safdar, MD, PhD, and Sanjay Saint, MD, MPH.
- Chapter 11. Ventilator-Associated Pneumonia: Brief Update ReviewBradford D Winters, PhD, MD and Sean M Berenholtz, MD, MHS.
- Chapter 12. Interventions To Allow the Reuse of Single-Use Devices: Brief Review (NEW)Meredith Noble, MS.
- Chapter 7. Barrier Precautions, Patient Isolation, and Routine Surveillance for Prevention of Health Care-Associated Infections: Brief Update Review
- Section C. Surgery, Anesthesia, and Perioperative Medicine
- Chapter 13. Preoperative Checklists and Anesthesia ChecklistsJonathan R Treadwell, PhD and Scott Lucas, PhD, PE.
- How Important Is the Problem?
- What Is the Patient Safety Practice?
- Why Should This Patient Safety Practice Work?
- What Are the Beneficial Effects of the Patient Safety Practice?
- What Are the Harms of the Patient Safety Practice?
- How Has the Patient Safety Practice Been Implemented, and in What Contexts?
- Are There Any Data About Costs?
- Are There Any Data About Adoption and Diffusion of This Patient Safety Practice?
- Conclusions and Comment
- References
- Chapter 14. Use of Report Cards and Outcome Measurements To Improve Safety of Surgical Care: American College of Surgeons National Quality Improvement Program (NEW)Melinda Maggard-Gibbons, MD, MSHS.
- How Important Is the problem?
- What Is the Patient Safety Practice?
- Why Should This Patient Safety Practice Work?
- What Are the Beneficial Effects of the Patient Safety Practice?
- What Are the Harms of the Patient Safety Practice?
- How Has the Patient Safety Practice Been Implemented, and in What Contexts?
- Are There Any Data About Costs?
- Are There Any Data About the Effect of Context on Effectiveness? Lessons Learned From Implementation at Different Sites
- Conclusions and Comment
- References
- Chapter 15. Prevention of Surgical Items Being Left Inside Patient: Brief Update ReviewJonathan R Treadwell, PhD.
- Chapter 16. Operating Room Integration and Display Systems: Brief Review (NEW)Fang Sun, MD, PhD.
- Chapter 17. Use of Beta Blockers To Prevent Perioperative Cardiac Events: Brief Update ReviewSumant R Ranji, MD and Paul G Shekelle, MD, PhD.
- Chapter 18. Use of Real-Time Ultrasound Guidance During Central Line Insertion: Brief Update ReviewPaul G Shekelle, MD, PhD and Paul Dallas, MD.
- Introduction
- What Is the Practice of Using Ultrasound Guidance for Central Venous Catheter Insertion?
- How Has the Use of Ultrasound To Guide Central Venous Catheter Insertion Been Implemented?
- What Have We Learned About the Use of Ultrasound Guidance for Central Venous Catheter Insertion?
- Conclusions and Comment
- References
- Chapter 13. Preoperative Checklists and Anesthesia Checklists
- Section D. Safety Practices Aimed Primarily at Hospitalized Elders
- Chapter 19. Preventing In-Facility FallsIsomi M Miake-Lye, BA, Susanne Hempel, PhD, David A Ganz, MD, PhD, and Paul G Shekelle, MD, PhD.
- How Important Is the Problem?
- What is the Patient Safety Practice?
- Why Should This Patient Safety Practice Work?
- What Are the Beneficial Effects of the Patient Safety Practice?
- What Are the Harms of the Patient Safety Practice?
- How Has the Patient Safety Practice Been Implemented, and in What Contexts?
- Are There Any Data About Costs?
- Are There Any Data About the Effect of Context on Effectiveness?
- Conclusions and Comment
- References
- Chapter 20. Preventing In-Facility DeliriumJames Reston, PhD, MPH.
- How Important Is the Problem?
- What Is the Patient Safety Practice?
- Why Should This Patient Safety Practice Work?
- What Are the Beneficial Effects of the Patient Safety Practice?
- What Are the Harms of the Patient Safety Practice?
- How Has the Patient Safety Practice Been Implemented, and in What Contexts?
- Are There Any Data About Costs?
- What Is Known About the Effect of Context on Outcomes?
- Conclusions and Comment
- References
- Chapter 19. Preventing In-Facility Falls
- Section E. General Clinical Topics
- Chapter 21. Preventing In-Facility Pressure UlcersNancy Sullivan, BA.
- How Important Is the Problem?
- What Is the Patient Safety Practice?
- Why Should This Patient Safety Practice Work?
- What Are the Beneficial Effects of the Patient Safety Practice?
- What Are the Harms of the Patient Safety Practice?
- How Has the Patient Safety Practice Been Implemented, and in What Contexts?
- Are There Any Data About Costs of Pressure Ulcer Prevention Programs?
- What Is Known About the Effect of Context on Outcomes?
- Conclusions and Comment
- References
- Chapter 22. Inpatient Intensive Glucose Control Strategies To Reduce Death and Infection (NEW)Devan Kansagara, MD, MCR, FACP.
- How Important Is the Problem?
- What Is the Patient Safety Practice?
- What Are the Beneficial Effects of the Patient Safety Practice?
- What Are the Harms of the Patient Safety Practice?
- How Has the Patient Safety Practice Been implemented, and in What Contexts?
- Are There Any Data About Costs?
- Are There Any Data About the Effect of Context on Effectiveness?
- Conclusions and Comment
- References
- Chapter 23. Interventions To Prevent Contrast-Induced Acute Kidney InjurySumant R Ranji, MD, Stephanie Rennke, MD, Yimdriuska Magan, BS, Erika Moseson, MD, and Robert M Wachter, MD.
- How Important Is the Problem?
- What Is the Patient Safety Practice?
- Why Should This Patient Safety Practice Work?
- What Are the Beneficial Effects of the Patient Safety Practice?
- What Are the Harms of the Patient Safety Practice?
- How Has the Patient Safety Practice Been Implemented, and in What Contexts?
- Are There Any Data About Costs of the Patient Safety Practice?
- Are There Any Data About the Effect of Context on Effectiveness?
- Conclusions and Comment
- References
- Chapter 24. Rapid-Response Systems (NEW)Bradford D Winters, MD, PhD, Sallie Weaver, PhD, and Sydney Dy, MD, MSc.
- How Important Is the Problem?
- What Is the Patient Safety Practice?
- Why Should This Patient Safety Practice Work?
- What Are the Beneficial Effects of the Patient Safety Practice?
- What Are the Harms of the Patient Safety Practice?
- How Has the Patient Safety Practice Been Implemented, and in What Contexts?
- Are There Any Data About Costs?
- Are There Any Data About the Effect of Context on Effectiveness?
- Conclusions and Comment
- References
- Chapter 25. Medication Reconciliation Supported by Clinical Pharmacists (NEW)Lisha Lo, MPH, Janice Kwan, MD, Olavo A Fernandes, BScPhm, PharmD, and Kaveh G Shojania, MD.
- How Important Is the Problem?
- What Is the Patient Safety Practice?
- What Are the Beneficial Effects of the Patient Safety Practice?
- What Are the Harms of the Patient Safety Practice?
- How Has the Patient Safety Practive Been Implemented, and in What Context?
- Are There Any Data About the Effect of Context On Effectiveness?
- Are There Any Data About Costs?
- Conclusions and Comment
- References
- Chapter 26. Identifying Patients at Risk for Suicide: Brief Review (NEW)Steven C Bagley, MD.
- Chapter 27. Strategies To Prevent Stress-Related Gastrointestinal Bleeding (Stress Ulcer Prophylaxis): Brief Update ReviewStephanie Rennke, MD, Robert M Wachter, MD, and Sumant R Ranji, MD.
- Introduction
- What Is Stress Ulcer Prophylaxis?
- What Is the Context for the Use of Stress Ulcer Prophylaxis?
- What Have We Learned About Stress Ulcer Prophylaxis?
- Recent Reviews and Systematic Evaluations
- No New Studies for Effectiveness of Acid Suppressive Therapy for Stress Ulcer Prophylaxis
- PPI Use and Misuse Have the Potential for Harm
- Costs and Implementation
- Conclusions and Comment
- References
- Chapter 28. Prevention of Venous Thromboembolism: Brief Update ReviewElliott R Haut, MD, FACS and Brandyn D Lau, MPH.
- Chapter 29. Preventing Patient Death or Serious Injury Associated With Radiation Exposure From Fluoroscopy and Computed Tomography: Brief Review (NEW)Nancy Sullivan, BA.
- Chapter 30. Ensuring Documentation of Patients' Preferences for Life-Sustaining Treatment: Brief Update ReviewSydney Dy, MD, MSc.
- Chapter 21. Preventing In-Facility Pressure Ulcers
- Section A. Adverse Drug Events
- Part 2b. Practices Designed To Improve Overall System/Multiple Targets
- Chapter 31. Human Factors and ErgonomicsPascale Carayon, PhD, Anping Xie, MS, and Sarah Kianfar, MS.
- How Important Is the Problem?
- What Is the Patient Safety Practice?
- Why Should This Patient Safety Practice Work?
- What Are the Beneficial Effects of the Patient Safety Practice?
- How Has the Patient Safety Practice Been Implemented, and in What Contexts?
- Are There Any Data About Costs of the Patient Safety Practice?
- Are There Any Data About the Effect of Context on Effectiveness?
- Conclusions and Comment
- References
- Chapter 32. Promoting Engagement by Patients and Families To Reduce Adverse Events (NEW)Zack Berger, MD, PhD, Tabor Flickinger, MD, and Sydney Dy, MD, MSc.
- How Important Is the Problem?
- What Is the Patient Safety Practice?
- Why Should This Patient Safety Practice Work?
- What Are the Beneficial Effects of the Patient Safety Practice?
- What Are the Harms of the Patient Safety Practice?
- How Has the Patient Safety Practice Been Implemented, and in What Contexts?
- Are There Any Data About Costs?
- Are There Any Data About the Effect of Context on Effectiveness?
- Conclusions and Comment
- References
- Chapter 33. Promoting a Culture of SafetySallie J Weaver, PhD, Sydney Dy, MD, MSc, Lisa H Lubomski, PhD, and Renee Wilson, MS.
- How Important Is the Problem?
- What Is the Patient Safety Practice?
- Why Should This Patient Safety Practice Work?
- What Are the Beneficial Effects of the Patient Safety Practice?
- What Are the Harms of the Patient Safety Practice?
- How Has the Patient Safety Practice Been Implemented, and in What Contexts?
- Are There Any Data About Costs?
- Are There Any Data About the Effect of Context on Effectiveness?
- Conclusions and Comment
- References
- Chapter 34. Effect of Nurse-to-Patient Staffing Ratios on Patient Morbidity and MortalityPaul G Shekelle, MD, PhD.
- How Important Is the Problem?
- What Is the Patient Safety Practice?
- Why Should This Patient Safety Practice Work?
- What Are the Beneficial Effects of the Patient Safety Practice?
- What Are the Harms of the Patient Safety Practice?
- How Has the Patient Safety Practice Been Implemented, and in What Contexts?
- Are There Any Data About Costs?
- Are There Any Data About the Effect of Context on Effectiveness?
- Conclusions and Comment
- References
- Chapter 35. Patient Safety Practices Targeted at Diagnostic Errors (NEW)Kathryn M McDonald, MM, Despina Contopoulos-Ioannidis, MD, Julia Lonhart, BS, BA, Brian Matesic, BS, Eric Schmidt, BA, Noelle Pineda, BA, and John PA Ioannidis, MD.
- How Important Is the Problem?
- What Is the Patient Safety Practice?
- Why Should This Patient Safety Practice Work?
- What Are the Beneficial Effects of the Patient Safety Practice?
- What Are the Harms of the Patient Safety Practice?
- How Has the Patient Safety Practice Been Implemented, and In What Contexts?
- Are There Any Data About Costs?
- Are There Any Data About the Effect of Context on Effectiveness?
- Conclusions and Comment
- References
- Chapter 36. Monitoring Patient Safety Problems (NEW)Fang Sun, MD, PhD.
- How Important Is the Problem?
- What Is the Patient Safety Practice?
- Why Should This Patient Safety Practice Work?
- What Are the Beneficial Effects of the Patient Safety Practice?
- What Are the Harms of the Patient Safety Practice?
- How Has the Patient Safety Practice Been Implemented, and in What Contexts?
- Are There Any Data About Costs?
- Are There Any Data About the Effect of Context on Effectiveness?
- Conclusions and Comment
- References
- Chapter 37. Interventions To Improve Care Transitions at Hospital Discharge (NEW)Stephanie Rennke, MD, Marwa H Shoeb, MD, MS, Oanh K Nguyen, MD, Yimdriuska Magan, BS, Robert M Wachter, MD, and Sumant R Ranji, MD.
- How Important Is the Problem?
- What Is the Patient Safety Practice?
- Why Should This Patient Safety Practice Work?
- What Are the Beneficial Effects of the Patient Safety Practice?
- What Are the Harms of the Patient Safety Practice?
- How Has the Patient Safety Practice Been Implemented, and in What Contexts?
- Are There Any Data About Costs?
- Are There Any Data About the Effect of Context on Effectiveness?
- Conclusions and Comment
- References
- Chapter 38. Use of Simulation Exercises in Patient Safety EffortsEric M Schmidt, BA, Sara N Goldhaber-Fiebert, MD, Lawrence A Ho, MD, and Kathryn M McDonald, MM.
- How Important Is the Problem?
- What Is the Patient Safety Practice?
- Why Should This Patient Safety Practice Work?
- What Are the Beneficial Effects of the Patient Safety Practice?
- How Has the Patient Safety Practice Been Implemented and in What Context?
- Are There Any Data About Costs?
- Are There Any Data About the Effect of Context on Effectiveness?
- Conclusions and Comment
- References
- Chapter 39. Obtaining Informed Consent From Patients: Brief Update ReviewKristina M Cordasco, MD, MPH, MSHS.
- Chapter 40. Team-Training in Health Care: Brief Update ReviewSallie J Weaver, PhD and Michael A Rosen, PhD.
- Chapter 41. Computerized Provider Order Entry With Clinical Decision Support Systems: Brief Update ReviewSumant R Ranji, MD, Stephanie Rennke, MD, and Robert M Wachter, MD.
- Introduction
- What Are Computerized Provider Order Entry With Clinical Decision Support Systems?
- How Have Computerized Provider Order Entry With Clinical Decision Support Systems Been Implemented?
- What Have We Learned About Computerized Provider Order Entry and Clinical Decision Support Systems Since the “Making Health Care Safer Report?”
- Conclusions and Comment
- References
- Chapter 42. Tubing Misconnections: Brief Review (NEW)Kelley Tipton, MPH.
- How Important Is the Problem?
- What Is the Patient Safety Practice?
- Why Should the Patient Safety Practice Work?
- What Are the Benefits of the Patient Safety Practice?
- What Are the Harms of the Patient Safety Practice?
- How Has the Patient Safety Practice Been Implemented, and in What Contexts?
- Conclusions and Comments
- References
- Chapter 43. Limiting Individual Providers' Hours of Service: Brief Update ReviewSumant R Ranji, MD and Robert M Wachter, MD.
- Chapter 31. Human Factors and Ergonomics
- Part 3. Discussion
- Abbreviations/Acronyms
- Appendix A Original List of Patient Safety Practices
- Appendix B AMSTAR: A Measurement Tool To Assess Systematic Reviews
- Appendix C Literature Searches and Topic-Specific Methods
- Appendix D Supplementary Evidence Tables
Prepared for: Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality, U.S. Department of Health and Human Services1, Contract No. 290-2007-10062-I. Prepared by: RAND Corporation, Santa Monica, CA, University of California, San Francisco/Stanford, San Francisco, CA, Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, MD, ECRI Institute, Plymouth Meeting, PA
Suggested citation:
Shekelle PG, Wachter RM, Pronovost PJ, Schoelles K, McDonald KM, Dy SM, Shojania K, Reston J, Berger Z, Johnsen B, Larkin JW, Lucas S, Martinez K, Motala A, Newberry SJ, Noble M, Pfoh E, Ranji SR, Rennke S, Schmidt E, Shanman R, Sullivan N, Sun F, Tipton K, Treadwell JR, Tsou A, Vaiana ME, Weaver SJ, Wilson R, Winters BD. Making Health Care Safer II: An Updated Critical Analysis of the Evidence for Patient Safety Practices. Evidence Report No. 211. (Prepared by the Southern California-RAND Evidence-based Practice Center under Contract No. 290-2007-10062-I.) AHRQ Publication No. 13-E001-EF. Rockville, MD: Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality. March 2013. www.ahrq.gov/research/findings/evidence-based-reports/ptsafetyuptp.html.
This report is based on research conducted by the Southern California-RAND Evidence-based Practice Center (EPC) under contract to the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (AHRQ), Rockville, MD (Contract No. 290-2007-10062-I). The findings and conclusions in this document are those of the authors, who are responsible for its contents; the findings and conclusions do not necessarily represent the views of AHRQ. Therefore, no statement in this report should be construed as an official position of AHRQ or of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services.
The information in this report is intended to help health care decisionmakers—patients and clinicians, health system leaders, and policymakers, among others—make well-informed decisions and thereby improve the quality of health care services. This report is not intended to be a substitute for the application of clinical judgment. Anyone who makes decisions concerning the provision of clinical care should consider this report in the same way as any medical reference and in conjunction with all other pertinent information, i.e., in the context of available resources and circumstances presented by individual patients.
This report may be used, in whole or in part, as the basis for development of clinical practice guidelines and other quality enhancement tools, or as a basis for reimbursement and coverage policies. AHRQ or U.S. Department of Health and Human Services endorsement of such derivative products may not be stated or implied.
None of the investigators have any affiliations or financial involvement that conflicts with the material presented in this report.
- 1
540 Gaither Road, Rockville, MD 20850; www
.ahrq.gov
- Making Health Care Safer IIMaking Health Care Safer II
Your browsing activity is empty.
Activity recording is turned off.
See more...