Clinical Description
The clinical presentation of arylsulfatase A deficiency (also known as metachromatic leukodystrophy or MLD) is heterogeneous with respect to the age of onset, the rate of progression, and the initial symptoms. Three clinical subtypes of MLD are primarily distinguished by age of onset:
Late-infantile MLD, comprising 50%-60% of affected individuals
Juvenile MLD, approximately 20%-40%
Adult MLD, approximately 10%-20%
The age of onset within a family is usually similar, but exceptions occur [Arbour et al 2000]. Although the presenting symptoms and age of onset vary, all individuals eventually develop complete loss of motor, sensory, and cognitive functions. The disease course may be from several years in the late-infantile-onset form to decades in the juvenile- and adult-onset forms [Gieselmann & Ingeborg 2019]. Death most commonly results from pneumonia or other infection. Life span correlates roughly with the age of onset but can be quite variable, particularly in the later-onset forms. Furthermore, the presenting symptoms appear to correlate with the rate of disease progression. Motor symptoms predict a faster deterioration compared to cognitive symptoms [Kehrer et al 2021].
Late-infantile MLD. Age of onset is before age 30 months, following a period of apparently normal development. In the initial stage, weakness, hypotonia, and depressed deep tendon reflexes are observed. Other presenting signs are coordination difficulties (e.g., clumsiness, frequent falls, delayed or abnormal walking, strabismus, nystagmus, and dysarthria), clonus/tremor, and cognitive changes (e.g., cognitive delays, irritability, extreme fatigue, and nocturnal awakenings) [Eichler et al 2022]. Symptoms may first be noted following anesthesia or a febrile illness and may subside for weeks before continuing to progress. Less commonly, seizures are the first neurologic sign. Peripheral neuropathy with slow nerve conduction velocities (NCVs) is common. Brain auditory and visual evoked response testing demonstrate impairment in hearing and vision [Kehrer et al 2011a, Fumagalli et al 2021].
As the disease progresses, language, cognitive development, and gross and fine motor skills regress. Peripheral neuropathy can lead to pain in the arms and legs. In one study, individuals with the late-infantile form had lost the ability to sit without support and to move by age three years, and all had lost both trunk and head control by age three years, four months [Kehrer et al 2011a]. Eventually spasticity becomes prominent and bulbar involvement can result in airway obstruction and feeding difficulties, requiring gastrostomy tube placement. Notably, one study found that gastrostomy tube placement did not prolong survival in a cohort with late-infantile MLD [Fumagalli et al 2021]. Generalized or partial seizures can occur, and vision and hearing become progressively compromised. Eventually, the child becomes bedridden with tonic spasms, decerebrate posturing, and general unawareness. Most children die within five years after the onset of symptoms, although survival can extend into the second decade of life with current levels of care.
Juvenile MLD. Age of onset is between ages 30 months and 16 years, with a median age of six years, two months [Gieselmann & Ingeborg 2019]. Symptoms start insidiously and can include motor symptoms such as difficulty with coordination, tremors, abnormal movements, and a regression of fine motor skills. Cognitive symptoms may also manifest, such as learning difficulties, concentration issues, and behavioral disorders (e.g., personality changes, impulsive behavior, sleep problems, and loss of interest in activities) [Kehrer et al 2014, Eichler et al 2022].
Some medical professionals distinguish between early-onset and late-onset juvenile MLD, and recent studies support measurable differences between these two subgroups [Fumagalli et al 2021, Kehrer et al 2021]. The early-onset juvenile form is typically diagnosed before the age of six years and shares many similarities with the late-infantile form. Some of the initial symptoms may include motor and gait disturbances. In contrast, the late-onset juvenile variant often presents initially with behavioral abnormalities, followed by a decline in school performance, language regression, and gait disturbances. For prognostic purposes, the age at onset and quality of symptoms should be considered, with presence of motor symptoms at onset being a negative prognostic factor [Kehrer et al 2021]. In general, the rate of motor deterioration is variable, but regardless of the age of onset, once motor deterioration begins, the regression tends to be rapid in all individuals with juvenile MLD [Kehrer et al 2011a]. Most individuals die before age 20 years, but survival is variable.
Adult MLD. Symptoms are first noted after sexual maturity (age ~16 years) but may not occur until the fourth or fifth decade. As with late-onset juvenile MLD, presenting symptoms vary. Initial signs are often related to cognitive dysfunction, such as emerging problems in school or job performance. Alcohol or drug use, poor money management, emotional lability, inappropriate affect, and frank psychosis often lead to psychiatric evaluation and an initial diagnosis of dementia, schizophrenia, or depression. In others, neurologic symptoms (weakness and loss of coordination progressing to spasticity and incontinence) predominate initially, leading to diagnoses of multiple sclerosis or other neurodegenerative diseases. Among published cases of adult MLD, 72% presented with dementia and behavioral difficulties, 16% with psychosis and schizophrenia, 28% with neuropathy, and 12% with seizures [Mahmood et al 2010]. Peripheral neuropathy is usually mild or not present.
The course is variable. Periods of relative stability may be interspersed with periods of decline. Inappropriate behaviors and poor decision making become problems for the family or other caregivers. Dressing and other self-help skills deteriorate. Eventually, bowel and bladder control are lost. As the disease advances, dystonic movements, spastic quadriparesis, or decorticate posturing occurs. Severe contractures and generalized seizures may occur. The duration of the disease ranges from several years to decades.
Other findings in MLD
MRI of the brain is a powerful tool to investigate the involvement of the central nervous system in this disease. MLD primarily affects the white matter, and its changes during the disease can be seen on T
2-weighted MRI as hyperintense areas. Several scoring systems have been developed to evaluate disease severity and progression consistently [
Eichler et al 2009,
Sessa et al 2016]. The initial pathologic hallmarks of the disease include changes in the signal of periventricular white matter and involvement of the corpus callosum [
Groeschel et al 2011,
Fumagalli et al 2021,
Schoenmakers et al 2022]. Longitudinal assessments show that the cerebellum is initially spared. Advanced MRI techniques and computational tools are being implemented to evaluate demyelination load and volume loss more accurately [
Amedick et al 2023,
Feldmann et al 2023].
Several studies have addressed the electrophysiologic findings of peripheral neuropathy in MLD and their progression over time. Studies show that both motor and sensory NCVs show uniform slowing, as is expected for a demyelinating polyneuropathy [
Raina et al 2019]. Measurement of NCVs is no longer necessary for diagnosis but can be used to monitor disease progression or responses in therapeutic trials.
Brain stem auditory evoked responses (BAERs) are frequently found to be abnormal in individuals with late-infantile MLD. When studying the progression of late-infantile MLD, it has been observed that central waves in BAERs tend to disappear early, which is contrary to the expected pattern of progressive shortening of the I-V interpeak latency seen in healthy children during the first years of life, reflecting normal brain stem myelination. However, the use of BAERs is less straightforward in individuals with juvenile and adult MLD. Some individuals may exhibit recordings that are close to normal or maintain stable I-V interpeak latencies despite experiencing psychomotor deterioration [
Fumagalli et al 2021].
Sulfatide accumulation has been found outside the central nervous system in other organs. Accumulation n the gallbladder, hyperplastic polyps, hemobilia, and gallbladder carcinoma has been reported [
van Rappard et al 2016b]. Polypoid masses in the stomach and duodenum complicated by intestinal intussusception have also been reported [
Yavuz & Yuksekkaya 2011].
Pathogenesis. MLD is a disorder of impaired breakdown of sulfatides (cerebroside sulfate or 3-O-sulfogalactosylceramide), sulfate-containing lipids that occur throughout the body and are found in greatest abundance in nervous tissue, kidneys, and testes. Sulfatides are critical constituents in the nervous system, where they comprise approximately 5% of the myelin lipids. Sulfatide accumulation in the nervous system eventually leads to myelin breakdown (leukodystrophy) and a progressive neurologic disorder [Gieselmann & Ingeborg 2019].
Prevalence
Arylsulfatase A deficiency (MLD). The overall prevalence of MLD has been reported to be between 1:40,000 and 1:170,000 in different populations [Gieselmann & Ingeborg 2019]. Assuming the prevalence stated, the overall carrier frequency is predicted to be between 1:100 and 1:200. Based on data from the Genome Aggregation Database (gnomAD), it is estimated that the frequency of pathogenic and likely pathogenic variants (allele frequency) in ARSA is approximately 1 in 360. Using the Hardy-Weinberg formula, this frequency suggests an overall incidence of 1:130,000 [Karczewski et al 2020]. This is likely an underestimate, as variants currently classified as of unknown significance may be pathogenic [Trinidad et al 2023]. The disorder is pan ethnic; however, most data come from European and North American populations.
The following populations have an increased prevalence of MLD due to the presence of founder variants (figures are approximate; see Table 6):
1:75 in Habbanite Jewsish population in Israel
1:8,000 in Israeli Arabs
1:2,500 in individuals of Yup'ik ancestry from Alakanuk, Alaska
1: 6,400 in individuals of Navajo ancestry from the western portion of the Navajo Nation in the United States
ARSA-PD alleles. The frequency of ARSA-PD variants is significantly higher as compared to ARSA-MLD variants. The p.Asn352Ser
ARSA-PD variant is commonly found in all populations examined, including African / African American (33.88%), Admixed American (27.81%), Middle Eastern (19.85%), Amish (18.09%), East Asian (16.40%), South Asian (14.73%), Ashkenazi Jewish (13.91%), European (non-Finnish) (12.68%), European (Finnish) (6.482%), and Other (14.85%) [Karczewski et al 2020] (see also gnomAD). Thus, individuals with biallelic ARSA-PD variants are more common than individuals with biallelic ARSA-MLD variants and individuals compound heterozygous for ARSA-PD/ARSA-MLD variants. ARSA-MLD variants can be found on a wild type allele or in cis on an ARSA-PD allele (ARSA-PD-MLD alleles).