What's in a Number? Examining the Effect of a Dedicated Research Year on H-Index and Fellowship Decision-making

Objective: To assess the effect of a dedicated research year on the h-indices of residents and the pursuit of fellowship within a heterogeneous group of urology programs. We previously demonstrated that urology residents with a dedicated research year produce more than 2 times the number of publications than their counterparts in 5-year programs. However, we did not give consideration to the impact of these publications.

Materials and methods: We obtained information on the publication output and pursuit of fellowship of graduates from the New York Section urology residency programs from 2009 to 2013. Data on peer-reviewed publications were obtained by PubMed query and h-index was documented from the Scopus database.

Results: During the 5-year study period, 148 individuals (116 M, 32 F) graduated from New York Section urology programs. The mean h-index was 4.6 for residents in 5-year programs compared with 8.1 for those in 6-year programs (P < .001). Residents with a dedicated research year were more likely to pursue fellowship training (79.3% vs 58.8%, P = .023) with no difference in the pursuit of accredited fellowship programs. Those residents who went on to fellowship training had a significantly higher h-index (6.2 vs 3.6, P = .001).

Conclusion: Urology residents with a dedicated research year have almost 2 times the h-indices of their counterparts. Residents who pursue fellowship training also have higher h-indices. Residents who completed a dedicated research year were more likely to pursue fellowship training, although the accreditation status of these programs was variable.