In colonial marine invertebrates, allorecognition restricts somatic fusion and thus, chimerism, to histocompatible individuals. Little is understood, however, about how invertebrates respond to chimerism formed across histocompatibility barriers or whether embryonic exposure to histoincompatible cells induces allotolerance. We here evaded natural allorecognition barriers by generating well mixed embryonic chimeras of Hydractinia symbiolongicarpus (Cnidaria:Hydrozoa) and developed molecular markers to detect chimerism in both histocompatible and histoincompatible settings. Histocompatible chimeras exhibited markedly higher growth rates and survivorship than histoincompatible pairings. Histoincompatible chimeras were unstable, with chimerism being undetectable by 4 wk of age. In contrast, colonies generated from histocompatible pairings remained chimeric at markedly higher frequencies and longer durations. Histoincompatible chimeras that lost detectable chimerism retained the fusibility/rejection characteristics of the remaining component of the chimera but not that of the lost component. Chimerism across histocompatibility barriers in an invertebrate model organism was unstable and did not induce tolerance.