Hereditary protein S (PS) deficiency predisposes to venous thrombosis. Previously, we demonstrated a difference in risk of venous thrombosis between PS deficiency type I and type III. We used direct sequencing, multiplex ligation-dependent probe amplification (MLPA), and linkage analysis to study whether this difference could be explained by molecular heterogeneity. The study contained two sets of families with PS deficiency type I (cohort 1; 35 probands, 155 relatives) or type III (cohort 2; 52 probands, 241 relatives). In cohort 1, a mixed type I/type III PS-deficient phenotype was observed in 66% of the pedigrees. A total of 34 probands carried a mutant PROS1 allele, compared to one proband in cohort 2 (P<10(-10)). The proband's mutation was identified in all type I, but only in 57% of type III PS deficient relatives. MLPA-analysis in the mutation negative families did not reveal PROS1 deletions or insertions. Linkage analysis in 16 families showed cosegregation of PROS1 markers in the family with type I deficiency, but not in the 15 families with type III deficiency. The genotype-phenotype associations point to differences in genetic architecture. Whereas PS deficiency type I is a monogenic disease due to PROS1 allelic heterozygosity, PS deficiency type III is most likely a more complex or heterogeneous disorder.